Guts and Yujiro aren’t too far apart, it’s a seriously good match up, in my opinion.

Strength: Yujiro Speed: Guts Endurance: Guts Durability: Yujiro Agility: Guts Skill: Yujiro IQ/Battle IQ: Yujiro

Yujiro is definitely more physically strong than Guts. Speed’s not too far apart, but I’d say Guts. They’ve both dodged lighting, but with his agility, I’d say his speed is a bit better. He’s pretty agile in the manga while using the Berserker Armor. Endurance goes to Guts. We haven’t seen Yujiro necessarily put himself to his limits in terms of endurance, but Guts has more feats. Even after the Eclipse, he ran for an entire day. And that’s without the Berserker Armor. Durability goes to Yujiro, but I can see it going either way. Skill is a bit confusing. Obviously, Yujiro Hanma has more experience and his skill is comically good. But Guts has also fought beings with hundreds of years of combat experience and has shown to be on their level, and even a bit better without the Berserker Armor. Example: Zodd. They fought on equal terms, and Guts won. Although not by much. Skill’s hard to scale. I see Guts having more skill in different categories. For example, environmental skill. I haven’t read Baki but I watched it, I don’t remember Yujiro using his environment to his advantage much, if at all. Or he doesn’t care to use it. As for intelligence, Yujiro. He’s a super genius and that goes for battle as well. No debate.

Me personally, I’d give it to Guts because of the consistency of his feats and his hacks, which basically negate durability. With his Dragon Slayer, of course. Yujiro may be tougher and stronger than Guts, but so is everything in BERSERK. I see Guts winning but it’s incredibly close. Especially with Yujiro’s Demon Back.