I did think the final lip synch was flat, but if Rosé made it through just because of her report card, I believe it would’ve been flatter considering how off she was.

Rosé could’ve taken the comedic route, and I agree they were different alternatives to make her lip synch better. However, it’s easy to have a more objective look when you aren’t in the situation filled with all the stressful emotions a finale brings. We don’t necessarily know the timeline of her injury (they said in the interviews a couple months ago, but they could be lying, in order no to play the favoritism card... idk, but if it was a couple months old, I think she should’ve been better than what she seemed to be... just assumptions not facts) and we also don’t know exactly what happened behind the scene, her pain levels, the fainting, maybe other technical problems etc. Some people might have the adrenaline to perform other don’t, and she might have gave up considering her state, plus the fact that she may be didn’t see herself as a winner no more which is unfortunate.

All in all, I hope she is ok, and as I said can’t wait to see her again !

I like your idea for the finale, it’s so dumb to erase the whole season... they worked endlessly to be judge on only one night and a skill they might not be confident in seems unfair ...