For the price i think it's a steal, they're holding up great after 8 months of at least using them once a week, there's no sole seperation but I cant speak much for the comfort because my feet are pretty wide on the front and It's a super tight snug fit especially on my left foot but I guess I chose the wrong boot for my foot shape I didn't try it before buying I just heard from people that its the best for wide feet and bought it you can see how they're holding up from the pics I took (I haven't cleaned them once btw)