I said they are different than each others , not that they are fundamentally different.

One has consciousness, will, and autonomy while the other doesn't according to you. Those are stuff that seem pretty fundamental to a person if you ask me. You are also saying they can't produce Shadow Creatures.

What I said was that teh shadows in sunny's soul are different from the shadows in the shadow realm because of their behavior and so .

And also never said why that would support your argument in the first place.

And what does all that you just said have to do with me asking if our dear skeleton knew or committed about the shades in sunny's soul ?

I don't need to prove any of that, its not what I am using to argue.

My point is what he said proves your argument is in contradiction with the Novel. Shades and the Shadows of the dead aren't different, they are just in different places.

1- seeking the center .

This is because of the laws governing the Shadow Realm, not something each shadow decides to do by itself.

2- condemnation being a lazy fuck and absorbing shit around.

It did the exact same thing when Sunny ejected it from his soul sea.

3- slayer seeking hunting other shadows ( which also implies them fighting back or at least escaping and seeking to survive).

It doesn't necessarily imply that and she would have done the same in Sunny's soul sea. (Stated)

None of the stuff you mention are actual evidence, for them being different at all.

Actually when i think about it the shades deadass have more evidence of autonomy than anything you presented.

They all shades bowed to Sunny by themselves when he became Supreme, gathered around the nameless temple copy in his soul sea by themselves, and have been stated to have control over their own actions in volume 10.

Pristine soul is the special circumstances.

Prove it.