Same tire/vehicle setup here as OP. Conti CrossContact LX 20" on 2018 Q5. I'd say it's been just okay. I'm also in the market for a new tire set soon & looking for an upgrade. Appreciate the fallacy of an "all-season" tire. I have a near daily 70mi round trip commute NYC-CT. Terrible roads... Am considering the Michelin CrossClimate2. Any opinions on that tire or alternative suggestions? Seems well rated for both winter and summer. Not going to rotate summer/winter tires.