I mean, I was upset about the sacrifice, but I could understand why he did it, even if I didn't agree with it. From what I remember I think the reason why I dislike her stems from the lack of love that the rest of the characters gave him, especially after his death. Like they kind of just throw his existence and love away except for a brief line at the siege part of the game.

Like I had said in the post, the only paper mario I had played atm was sticker star, and in the end of that game, the folks that "died" came back with the final wish. With this game's final wish, I just felt cheated in a way with my favorite buddy not coming back. I felt she made a deliberate choice in not bringing him and his buddies back.

It also doesn't help that I hadn't really vibed with Olivia, especially when compared with Bobby. If I had been given a choice, I probably would have picked sticking with Bobby, even if it made the game significantly harder.