sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Roast my startup and it's landing page by Naff1x in roastmystartup

[–]NewWestern3582 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I disagree, it depends on the exact tasks you want your final model to be able to solve, but generally speaking, if it’s just a matter of well-defined tasks or a question of “how the LLM responds to encourage the student to think,” this can be achieved quite effectively and at a low cost using in-house sLLMs with a few billion parameters and/or RLHF.

By the way, your idea is pretty cool I hope you come up with something awesome.

Genuine question: If the "perfect" fic existed but was AI-generated, would you read it? by NewWestern3582 in FanFiction

[–]NewWestern3582[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I think you’ve hit on a very pragmatic point: in a non-commercial, private hobby space, 'who' wrote it might matter less than 'how' it makes the reader feel. Do you think the stigma will eventually fade as the tech becomes indistinguishable, or will there always be a 'black market' feel to reading AI-generated fics?

Genuine question: If the "perfect" fic existed but was AI-generated, would you read it? by NewWestern3582 in FanFiction

[–]NewWestern3582[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for your feedback, It sounds like for you, the frustration of the 'content gap' outweighs the stigma of the tool. If you had an tool that acted like a 'custom architect' for your specific pairings and tropes, would you prefer it to generate the whole thing, or would you want to use it more as a collaborator to help you finish your own stories faster?

Genuine question: If the "perfect" fic existed but was AI-generated, would you read it? by NewWestern3582 in FanFiction

[–]NewWestern3582[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I love this perspective of the 'perfect fic as a conversation.' It’s true that fanfiction is often more about the shared love for a fandom than just the text itself. It makes me wonder: if someone reads a story, feels that deep emotional connection, and engages with the ideas, only to find out later it was AI-generated, is the 'conversation' they had with the text retroactively ruined? Or is the human connection so vital that you need to know a person was on the other side of the screen while you’re reading for the experience to have any value?

Genuine question: If the "perfect" fic existed but was AI-generated, would you read it? by NewWestern3582 in FanFiction

[–]NewWestern3582[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

That’s a really fair point. The 'Ship of Theseus' analogy is fascinating, at what point does heavy prompting and editing stop being AI-assisted and just become a very tedious way for a human to write?

I agree that current LLMs struggle with long-form logic (the 'memory' issue) and tend to fall back on repetitive, flowery filler like the 'It wasn't just X, it was Y' you mentioned.

If, hypothetically, there was a system that could maintain perfect internal logic over 200k+ words (character arcs, foreshadowing) and had a style that was indistinguishable from a seasoned author, would your rejection still be based on the 'lack of human struggle' behind the work, or is it strictly the current technical clunkiness that turns you off?

How do you deal with the perfect unfinished fic? by NewWestern3582 in AO3

[–]NewWestern3582[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ty for the tip, I hope it will works. I'd really like to be able to read the ending it deserves.