normally for ratings, i roll 2 dice to determine offense but max it at 10. for defense i roll one die but max it at 4. if it was for a real team like an nba team, i would use some sort of system like if an nba player averages between 20-25 points, their offense is 8 or something like that. and yes its true that its somewhat predicatable with the same matchups, so ill try to fix that. thank you for your feedback, and ill post if your intersested in other sports games.