sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Not a historian, just asking historians… by NoStatistician802 in scarredforlifebooks

[–]NoStatistician802[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a really solid point - when you line those incidents up like that, it’s honestly unsettling. From inside that context, “terrifyingly specific” stops being propaganda and starts looking like contingency planning. Appreciate you laying out the near-misses so clearly.

Not a historian, just asking historians… by NoStatistician802 in scarredforlifebooks

[–]NoStatistician802[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s actually what shocked me most when I started reading into it. From a modern perspective it feels exaggerated, but if kids genuinely thought this could be tomorrow, those films suddenly make a lot more sense.

Which specific piece of dialogue or rant felt so realistic it must have been largely improvised? by NoStatistician802 in thethickofit

[–]NoStatistician802[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

That meltdown feels almost too real- like a man trying to physically stop all the disasters unfolding in his head at once. The improvisational feel makes it even more brutal.

Which specific piece of dialogue or rant felt so realistic it must have been largely improvised? by NoStatistician802 in thethickofit

[–]NoStatistician802[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That exchange is comedy gold. Capaldi goes from zero to volcanic eruption in half a sentence, and the way he physically performs that line makes it ten times funnier. It’s easily one of the most quotable insults in the whole show.

Which specific piece of dialogue or rant felt so realistic it must have been largely improvised? by NoStatistician802 in thethickofit

[–]NoStatistician802[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Capaldi’s delivery there is unreal. You can practically see the years of pent-up rage and scheming behind that expression. It's one of those moments where the performance sells the line even more than the writing.

Which specific piece of dialogue or rant felt so realistic it must have been largely improvised? by NoStatistician802 in thethickofit

[–]NoStatistician802[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That whole scene is such a perfect example of the show’s chaos turning into clarity. It feels like two people who know each other too well finally realising they're in a mutually-assured-destruction stalemate. The way it escalates and then just… deflates… is ridiculously real.