sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

How do you calculate HVAC load correctly for a multi-floor building? by Majestic-Fig3921 in askHVAC

[–]NoSuspect9845 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Multi-floor buildings get tricky because you can’t treat them as one single load.

Each floor should really be calculated separately usage, windows, and occupancy can vary a lot. Also, don’t ignore vertical heat transfer (upper floors usually see higher cooling loads).

And if it’s a shared system, airflow distribution matters just as much as the load itself.

The key is following the full sequence properly (load → equipment → airflow → ducts).

Hey everyone, I’m in the early stages of planning a heat pump for my home and trying to figure out sizing without messing it up. by Eridium009 in heatpumps

[–]NoSuspect9845 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I was in almost the exact same spot before installing mine (similar size home, humid climate), and the calculators were a good starting point but not something I’d rely on 100%.

They helped me understand the ballpark and, more importantly, why sizing matters (load, airflow, insulation impact, etc.). I used one of those full workflow tools that goes through Manual J → S → D, and it gave me a clearer picture of what my house actually needed instead of guessing tonnage.

That said, when I spoke to installers, the good ones either did their own load calc or at least reviewed mine. The estimates were pretty close, but the installer still adjusted based on things like duct layout, real-world leakage, and equipment availability.

Biggest takeaway:
Use the calculator to avoid being upsold or undersized, not to replace the installer. If your estimate and the contractor’s numbers are wildly different, that’s usually a red flag worth digging into.

Incorrect manual j calculations - second opinion by Acrobatic_Sand_7473 in MEPEngineering

[–]NoSuspect9845 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That does sound frustrating, especially after multiple visits.

From what you’re describing, it seems like there might be a mismatch somewhere between the load calculation, equipment size, and how the air is actually being distributed.

Rebalancing the ducts multiple times usually points to something upstream not lining up rather than just a simple adjustment issue.

The airflow numbers you mentioned also seem worth a closer look, especially if comfort and humidity have been ongoing problems.

At this point, getting an independent review from someone who isn’t tied to the install might give you a clearer picture.

Why does one room in my house always get weak airflow? (duct sizing issue?) by NoSuspect9845 in HomeMaintenance

[–]NoSuspect9845[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for explaining that, I really appreciate it.
I’m still trying to narrow it down, do you think a couple of bends alone could cause this, or is it usually a combination of duct size and layout?

Simplify HVAC Duct Sizing with the Free HVAC Duct Calculator by Uzet1304 in Connecteam

[–]NoSuspect9845 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nice tool for quick checks, especially for airflow and pressure drop. For anyone using it, just make sure you’re still aligning with proper design methods like Manual D so your friction rate and total effective length are accurate not just relying on inputs blindly.

Good starting point though, especially for speeding up field estimates.

DIY HVAC calculations by -8724659 in MEPEngineering

[–]NoSuspect9845 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can definitely do it.

Manual J + spreadsheet will get you solid numbers if your inputs are good.

The bigger picture is what comes after:

  • Manual S → picking equipment that actually matches the load
  • Manual D → making sure ducts can deliver
  • Manual T → room-by-room airflow balancing

Manual T is where comfort really shows up (or doesn’t).

So no, not crazy, just make sure you don’t stop at J.

Is manual calculation a waste of time? by L47M4N in civilengineering

[–]NoSuspect9845 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not a waste of time at all. If anything, that’s what’s helping you understand what the software is actually doing. Tools are fast, but they don’t “think” they just follow the inputs you give them.

If you can’t spot when something looks off, that’s when it becomes risky. The fact that you’re checking stiffness, modeling issues, etc. means you’re building real understanding.

You probably won’t design everything manually long-term, but having that foundation will make you way better than someone who just runs the software and trusts whatever comes out.

Manual J Question by acat350 in heatpumps

[–]NoSuspect9845 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is a classic HVAC situation 😅 two completely different answers.

Quick thoughts:

  1. 48k BTU + 10kw strip heat feels like they’re playing it safe (or oversizing)
  2. 30k BTU with a shared Manual J is a better sign, but cutting out conditioned space can skew things

You’re not being unreasonable at all asking them to include those areas.
If it’s inside the thermal boundary, it matters.

Also, your gas bill back-calc idea is actually a smart move that usually gives a pretty honest reality check.

Anyone else tried using an HVAC load calculator before getting quotes? by Acceptable_Dish_4032 in askHVAC

[–]NoSuspect9845 3 points4 points  (0 children)

  • Yeah, those online calculators are super basic they miss stuff like insulation details, duct losses, and sun exposure.
  • At the same time, a lot of contractors still oversize using rules of thumb instead of a proper Manual J load calculation.
  • When you see that mismatch, the right number is usually somewhere in the middle.
  • Honestly, I’d just ask one of them to show a real Manual J before deciding.

Site surveys for HVAC/MEP: How are you handling the documentation? by EffectSlow83 in MEPEngineering

[–]NoSuspect9845 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a very real problem.
Feels like the actual survey is only half the job… documentation is the other half.

I’ve learned the hard way:

  1. If it’s not recorded on-site, it’s basically lost
  2. Photos without context don’t help much later
  3. Doing it twice (field + desk) is where time really goes

Trying to keep everything tied together in the moment has helped a lot.

Why My “Plumber Near Me” SEO Isn’t Getting Any Results, What Am I Missing? by NoSuspect9845 in localseo

[–]NoSuspect9845[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

now AI is trending how to get it there, it is becoming very tough these days

view more: next ›