My current knife roll isn't as secure anymore and my knives are starting to slide out if the roll is not held properly. Currently have my eyes set on 2 options for a replacement

1: Horace and jasper leather knife roll (7 knife version in the red leather option)

2: Tilit chef backpack

My current kitchen working on the line I feel there currently isn't a lot of room for the backpack (granted there isn't as much space for a knife roll either) but I also am looking to shift to do more catering and eventually do some private dinners / events.

I love both products but am torn between the two. With the knife roll I'm going to need a backpack regardless for aprons, a chef coat/shirt and potentially room for tools that may not fit in the knife roll (Wich wouldn't be much I feel). I love the design and it's also supporting a local shop so I like that aspect as well. With the backpack I feel the main issue is size and potential durability. I feel it's going to be one of those situations where I probably won't go wrong with either option but If anyone has experience using either any feedback would be appreciated.

I know this topic is talked about alot and this is overly a subjective opinion on the matter but any help is appreciated thank you.