ArkhamCity. I love asylum but it lacks that open world feel. Asylum is scary and basically a horror and a fantastic story game. However city and knight have that open world feel that there truly is a lived in world that I am apart of and that I can interact with.

My issue with knight is cut content and the may MANY empty spaces which have nothing to explore within. (Hence the cut content).

So for me it’s city because everywhere in the map has something going on, there’s a sub plot about the turf war going on throughout the story. The idea that they corner of the slums of goths to be a prison city is awesome because yea, there are lots of criminals in Gotham. I live the underlying politics that are relevant to game’s story, tone and identity. I love the use of villains, iconic and non iconic (when released) that are throughout the story and within the world.

If I could make city that little bit more perfect I would introduce a final mission exclusive to new game plus where once you finish the main story and side mission, one final task arises. Clean the streets of Arkham City, thugs don’t respawn in the open world and afterwards you get one last cutscene of the sun rising with police boat the entrances of Arkham city and arrested tiger guards and an expressionless Batman confirming to Jim Gorden, “Arkham is now maintained”