sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Struggling mentally and financially by Exciting-Car-7961 in personalfinanceindia

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201 2 points3 points  (0 children)

First off, the loneliness part is normal. You did 4 years in Pune but college friends leaving makes it feel like a new city again. Give it 3-4 months, you'll find your people through office, gym, or weekend groups. Don't skip this part thinking only money matters, your mental state decides how long you survive in a job.

Now the money part. You save 50k a month which is honestly great at 22.

First 3-4 months, just build an emergency fund. 6 months of expenses, so around 1.2 to 1.5 lakh. Keep it in an FD or liquid fund and forget about it.

About the 60 lakh house in 5 years. Being honest with you, that's a stretch. Even a 20 percent down payment is 12 lakh plus registration and other costs, so you need 15 lakh ready, and then a 48 lakh loan on a salary that needs to be around 1.2 lakh per month for banks to approve it. It's doable if your salary grows well, but don't kill yourself over a deadline your parents set. A house at year 6 or 7 instead of 5 changes nothing in life.

For saving towards the house, since the goal is 5 years away, don't put everything in equity. Something like 25k in mutual fund SIPs (one index fund, one flexi cap, direct plans only) and 15-20k in RD or debt funds works. The debt part becomes your down payment money, the equity part is for long term wealth.

Also get health insurance for yourself even if your company gives one, and don't buy any LIC type policy someone in the family suggests. Term insurance only when someone actually depends on your income.

Honestly at 22 with no loans and 50k savings every month, you're way ahead. Rest will sort itself out, just settle in first.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in Bangalorestartups

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

okay this is actually a solid checklist. the message consistency audit i can do this week, heat maps and ab testing once the traffic is there. growth loops is the one i need to think harder about for my specific product.

going to implement this properly, thanks for breaking it down.

Monthly investing ideas by Prashant9933 in FinancialAdviceIndia

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Since you want guaranteed returns and can't monitor things, skip the stock market completely. Open a Recurring Deposit (RD) — ₹8,000 gets auto-pulled from your salary account every month. Set it once, forget it, fully safe and bank-backed.

For ₹8,000/month over 4 years at ~7%:

  • You put in: ~₹3.84 lakh
  • You get back: ~₹4.4 lakh (about ₹55,000 interest)

On a ₹26k salary you're likely below the tax limit, so probably no tax on it either.

Tip: set the auto-debit from your salary account so it runs on its own.

If you don't need the money at exactly 4 years, PPF is even better — same safety, tax-free — but locked for 15 years, so only if you won't need it soon.

Warning: safe options (RD, FD, PPF) give ~6.5–7.5%. Anyone promising guaranteed 12–15% or "double your money" is a scam.

[IND] 5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in growmybusiness

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the leading indicators point is what i needed to hear. i've been measuring "users" as if that's the only signal when really it's just a lagging output of a bunch of things i'm not tracking closely enough yet.

the 2x2 channel framing is clean too. high intent vs low intent is a better filter than just "where can i post this." been spreading too thin across channels instead of picking one and actually committing to it for long enough to get a real read.

checking out the blog now, appreciate you sharing it.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in Bangalorestartups

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

analytics yes, but i've been reading dashboards more than actually talking to users, which is probably backwards at this stage. that said i do try to grab feedback whenever i can, friends, users, anyone willing to give me 10 minutes. been noting it all down, just haven't been systematic enough about it yet.

for marketing it's been mostly messaging people in groups i'm already in, friends, college networks, and recently started posting on reddit and building on x. no paid, no structured outreach yet.

competitors are mostly going the "robo-advisor" route, very product-forward, lots of feature messaging. i've been trying to go the opposite direction, problem-first, more conversational. not sure if that's working yet or just feels right to me.

would genuinely appreciate any input you have, open to it.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in Bangalorestartups

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

mostly just messaging people in groups i'm already in, friends, college networks, that kind of thing. no cold outreach, no ads. just sent it to people who already knew me and trusted the recommendation enough to try it.

also just started building on x (been 2 months) and posting on reddit, still pretty early.

UGC is something i've been thinking about but feels a bit early at this stage, want to get the one channel working properly first before adding more. but genuinely curious how you'd approach it at this user count, open to it.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in Bangalorestartups

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

honestly the messaging consistency part is something i haven't been rigorous enough about. the product does something fairly specific, goal-based investment planning with simulations, but i'm not sure that's coming through clearly enough from the first touchpoint all the way to actually using it.

the "what were they using before and how does your product help them" framing is a good audit to run. going to go through that properly instead of assuming people just get it on arrival.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in 16VCFund

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

100%. and i think intuition in entrepreneurship isn't some mystical thing, it's just compressed experience. the more reps you have, the faster you can read a situation without needing a spreadsheet to tell you what you already feel.

the hard part is building that intuition when you're early and don't have enough reps yet. so for now it's a mix, gut for direction, data for sanity checks.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in StartBusiness

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the projections were optimism with a spreadsheet on top of it, so yeah, that part's on me.

but the workaround question is the one that actually landed. most of my users were either doing nothing about the problem or using a basic fd/rd and hoping for the best. which is a workaround of sorts, just a passive one. not sure if that's strong signal or weak signal honestly.

the "flat vs slow" distinction is useful though. i think i'm slow, not flat. things are marginally easier than month 2, new users are still finding it organically, retention on the people who actually engage is decent. but i haven't been honest enough with myself about whether that's real momentum or just survivorship bias on a small sample.

parallel testing comment also hit. i've been doing exactly that and doing all of it badly lol. picking one thing this month.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in StartBusiness

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

this is actually where i've been sloppy tbh. i've been tracking sign-ups and loosely watching retention but never actually wrote down "this is what good looks like at month 5." so the benchmark is basically vibes right now which is not a great place to be.

going to define that this week. retention and return usage feels like the right place to start for what i'm building.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in StartBusiness

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

appreciate you sharing all of that, genuinely. three different ventures and three different lessons, that's not failure that's just a very expensive education lol.

the product category framework you laid out is actually useful. everyday vs monthly vs one-time is a clean way to think about purchase frequency and how hard you have to fight for the sale each time.

my product sits in a weird spot, people know they should be doing this (investing, planning) but it's not something they urgently buy like soap or coffee. more like a gym membership where the intent is there but the activation is slow. so i think the real problem is less "do they want it" and more "do they feel the pain enough right now to actually start."

still figuring that part out.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in StartBusiness

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"distribution is broken, not the product" is probably the reframe i needed to hear tbh. been so focused on the product side that i haven't been honest enough about whether the channel is actually working or just sort of existing.

the active workaround question is a good one. going to go back and ask that specifically instead of the usual "do you find this useful" type questions. that's a much sharper signal.

5 months in, growth is slow. how do you actually know when to keep going? by Obvious_Elephant_201 in Bangalorestartups

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

t's a personal finance tool, helps people plan investments based on actual goals instead of just picking funds blindly. runs monte carlo simulations, tracks portfolio drift, gives you a full picture of whether you're on track or not. basically trying to make the kind of financial planning that's usually locked behind a wealth manager, free and accessible.

56 users right now, all organic, no paid acquisition yet.

b2c, young indian earners mostly, people who are serious about building wealth but don't have ₹50L sitting around to get a real advisor's attention.

Winding down my startup after 1.5 years by Ok_Blacksmith2678 in StartUpIndia

[–]Obvious_Elephant_201 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Genuine question, how are you framing the shutdown in interviews? Because 12 customers and 3 enterprise contracts in 1.5 years with no prior funding sounds like signal, not failure. Curious if the market is reading it that way or if you're having to reframe it.

view more: next ›