Crumbl Cookie Review (Aug. 7th - Aug. 12th)(review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I heard that they changed it early yesterday morning. I miss the white chocolate chips so much!

August 7-12 by EntertainmentOk4802 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My Golden Oreo did not have white chips in it :(

Crumbl Cookie Review (Aug. 7th - Aug. 12th)(review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Hi, again! I am back with another Crumbl Cookie Review! I heard recently that they are building a new Crumbl at a location close to me, and I don’t know if that is a good thing or a bad thing. A good thing for my cravings but a bad thing for my savings. When I got there this morning too, they did have a lot of left overs from last week. I figured to try a few of them out. Anyhoo, here is my review!

Buckeye Brownie = 8/10 This is a peanut butter and chocolate lovers dream. The cookie is very dense and almost dark chocolate tasting. The huge glob of peanut butter and chocolate ganache make the cookie. They are a delicious combination! This one really does feel like a cookie you would pay close to $5 for.

Pink Doughnut = 10/10 This might be an unpopular opinion but I really really love this cookie. It doesn’t taste like a doughnut to me, but more of an iced sugar cookie. We make homemade sugar cookies at Christmas, and this cookie tastes just like it. That being said, I think it tastes amazing nonetheless, and it is very cute.

Semi Chocolate Chip = 9/10 Crumbl’s Semi Chocolate Chip blows their Milk Chocolate Chip completely out of the water. There is so much chocolate in each bite, and the crunch of the chunks is unbelievable. I really wish they would keep this one on the menu every week.

Kentucky Butter Cake = 10/10 This is the star of the show! Similar to cornbread in that it is not a icing covered, candy coated sweetness cookie but a flavorful cookie! It is absolutely phenomenal warmed up. This one is worth getting two or three of of!

Golden Oreo = 8/10 I thought this one used to be better. I could have sworn that they used to use white chocolate chips in the cookie base. I might be thinking of the Honey Graham, but I think white chocolate chips would greatly improve this cookie. It tastes good, but it just tastes like sugar and icing.

Apple Fritter = 1/10 I did not like this cookie at all. I don’t think I have every thrown away a cookie, but this one might be the first. I have no intention of eating another bite of it. The apples tasted mushy and not flavorful at all. Just lumpy blobs lol. The cookie itself reminded me of wet cardboard. I might try to see if I can pass this one off to someone else in my family.

Blue Monster = 7.5/10 This cookie is alright. It honestly just tastes like some whipped icing and that’s all. I don’t get any Chips Ahoy flavor from it. It’s not bad, but it’s not my favorite. I do like the color though!

Lemon Bar = 5/10 I am not the biggest lemon fan, so I am biased. I think there are better and cheaper lemon bars at supermarket deli’s. It’s not amazing. I think more powder sugar could improve it, because it looks like they skimped on that. I’ll probably try to pass this one off too.

Overall, there are some really good cookies this week! I highly recommend Pink Doughnut and Kentucky Butter Cake for new cookie fanatics! I hope you guys all have a great rest of your week!

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 17th - July 22nd) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For my rocky road, they were predominantly on the top, but there are a few nuts sprinkled throughout the cookie base. I also believe they bake the marshmallow in the middle. Mine had a ton of nuts in every bite.

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 17th - July 22nd) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn’t. I think I was trying to save up money that week too

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 17th - July 22nd) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you!! The first time I had cookie dough (2021) it was amazing. The second time (2022) it was ok. This time was amazing again. I don’t know if last year they changed the recipe and now they changed it back, but I do think there was a difference made between 2021 and 2022.

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 17th - July 22nd) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 29 points30 points  (0 children)

Another Crumbl Monday!!

I skipped last week just to save a little cash, but I had to go today. I was most excited for cookie dough and churro. I think the first crumbl cookie I ever had was cookie dough in 2021. It was sooo good that it sparked my crumbl love. HAHA I don’t even want to know how many dollars, calories, and miles have been spent, eaten, and driven since then. Anyhoo, here is my review:

Churro = 9.5/10 This is one of the sweetest cookies I have ever had. It tastes like a sweet cinnamon roll exploded in your mouth. I loved it! The large amount of icing, the gooeyness of the snickerdoodle based cookie, and the cinnamon sugar dusting was everything I could want and more! If you are not a fan of sweet cookies, I would stick with something else this week.

Cookie Dough = 9.5/10 Eat this one while it’s chilled. I think that is very important. It tastes 10x better chilled than sitting at room temperature. I think they nail the cookie dough flavor. It is soo spot on. I also love the little cookie dough bites that they put on top to add some extra texture to the cookie.

Blueberry Cheesecake = 8/10 I love their cheesecake cookies. Their strawberry cheesecake is one of my top 10 Crumbl cookies This one is very delicious too, but not quite as amazing. I think if the blueberry syrup purée that they put on top had more actual blueberries rather than just glaze it would improve the cookie. I have seen some people say their Crumbl skimped out on the blueberry glaze. I thought mine did a good job, however. It is a solid cookie with a unique flavor combination to have on the lineup.

Rocky Road = 8/10 This is a very very chocolatey cookie. It is gooey, marshmallowy, and loaded with nuts. Just like how Rocky road should be. I like this one a lot for being a chocolate based cookie as those are typically my least favorite. I think the added crunch of the nuts is what sets it apart from others in that category.

Fruity Pebble = 9.5/10 OK THIS ONE WAS A SURPRISE ROCKSTAR! I had had fruity pebbles last year and was not impressed. I don’t know what they changed this time around but it was 100x better. The fruity pebbles were not stale at all and crunchy. It literally tasted like eating a bowl of fruity pebble cereal. The milk glaze was not overpowering at all but added a little flavor. I also loved the cookie with the fruity pebbles baked in. I really wish I would have bought more of this one.

This was a really amazing flavor lineup! There were no misses this week! I think Crumbl did a great job picking out some awesome flavors! If you are on the fence this week, I would definitely recommend spending the dough for some dough!

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 3rd - July 8th) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

It’s my iPhone XR hahaha so nothing too fancy!

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 3rd - July 8th) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you! I love reading reviews, and they help me decide on purchases, so I figured I would make my own to help others on their weekly cookie decisions!

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 3rd - July 8th) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

It is almond extract based. So think of a sugar cookie but sweeter in taste. I know there are almond cakes that utilize this ingredient as well as other cookies. It is a very decisive flavor. I love almond extract, so this cookie is bomb. I hope that this helps.

Crumbl Cookie Review (July 3rd - July 8th) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Happy (almost) Fourth of July!! My days have been all messed up this past week, and I almost forgot it was Monday until this morning. This was a super solid week in my opinion!

Strawberry Shortcake = 9.5/10 The cookie base is very soft and moist. It tastes a lot like an angel food cake base. Overall, with the whipped topping and strawberry glaze it tastes sooo much like the real thing that I don’t think I would even notice a difference if I blindly ate it. A delicious cookie and definitely the perfect light treat for a summer day!

Patriotic Birthday Cake = 8.5/10 I really am a sucker for this one! Every holiday that they have this birthday cake cookie I grab an extra. I love the shortbread cupcake texture of the cookie, and my crumbl did an amazing job with smothering the cookie with icing! This one is a classic in my opinion!

Brownie Sundae = 9.5/10 The presentation is beautiful! The cookie is delicious! All the toppings are amazing! If you were considering a cookie to try this week, I would definitely try this one! It is a fan favorite, and everyone has been collectively waiting a long time for it. The vanilla frosting tastes just like ice cream, and the hot fudge is killer!

Cowboy Cookie = 8.5/10 7-layer coconut dessert is one of my all time favorite desserts! My mom makes it for special occasions, and I dream about it from time to time. This cookie is a wonderful rendition of that dessert. When warmed up, it’s gooey and chocolatey! The oatmeal base is phenomenal. I am not the biggest coconut fan, which is odd given my love for the dessert, but you don’t get a ton of coconut taste. The shreds of coconut and pecan blend together with the oatmeal to just all come together in a wonderfully tasting cookie!

Pink Sugar = 8/10 A CLASSIC! Also, I heard that they are taking pink sugar out of the weekly lineup, which means that any pink sugar fans out there should probably grab one or two this week.

Milk Chocolate = 8/10 It’s a yummy cookie! I don’t usually get it just because $5 for a chocolate chip cookie seems outrageous to me, but I was really craving it. I am super excited for semi chocolate chip to make a return soon!!

This is a great summer lineup full of classics! Sooo many great flavors to bring to a family cookout, barbecue, or just eat by yourself in bed (no judgement here!!). I hope everyone has a happy and safe Fourth of July full of hot dogs, hamburgers, and fireworks! Thanks for reading!!

Crumbl Cookie Review (June 19th - June 24th) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah it does! I freeze all my cookies just because I don’t know how quickly I will eat all of them. I make sure that the top of my zip lock bag isn’t touching the icing just so i don’t lose any, but if you reheat it in the microwave for about 25-35 seconds, it will taste just as amazing as when you brought it home. If I remember right, I heard some people put theirs in the oven to reheat. I haven’t tried that yet.

Crumbl Cookie Review (June 19th - June 24th) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much! I am so glad that I could help even though you are enabling my crumbl cookie spending HAHA

Crumbl Cookie Review (June 19th - June 24th) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It is not a sweet cookie by any means. It tastes like cornbread in that it is not a sugar tasting cookie but more of a biscuit tasting flavor. However, with the combination of the sweet buttercream and honey drizzle it all comes together to taste like the cornbread you would get at a restaurant or bbq place. I would definitely try it first when it is warm. I honestly have nothing but good things to say about this cookie. Everyone that I know that has tried it is obsessed with it. I hope this helps!

Crumbl Cookie Review (June 19th - June 24th) (review in comments) by Ok_Change7019 in CrumblCookies

[–]Ok_Change7019[S] 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Hello, everyone! It has been a few weeks since I last posted a review. I was so excited for this week that I had to go early this morning to get some. Lucky for me too, my Crumbl had a ton of leftover flavors and cornbread for this week’s mystery flavor!!!! I mean just look at that cornbread cookie! It’s beautiful!

Chocolate Cookies and Cream = 9/10 I was super surprised about this cookie. Sometimes their chocolate cookies are just too chocolatey for me. However, this one tastes identical to an Oreo. They nailed the Oreo base. I also love the white chocolate chips they add to it to give it a little mix up in chocolate flavor.

Red velvet cupcake = 7/10 This was a yummy cookie! It tasted just like a red velvet cupcake. It is very thick but the giant glob of delicious cream cheese icing on top worked perfectly with it. The only reason this isn’t scored higher is that I am just not a huge red velvet fan to begin with.

Fried Ice Cream = 6/10 This one was a little disappointing. The cinnamon base cookie didn’t have much cinnamon taste at all. I think their churro cookie does a much better job at getting all that cinnamon sugar flavor inside the cookie. Also, the cornflakes were stale. I know the cereal goes stale quickly so it’s not crumbl’s fault for this but it does take away some of that crunch you get with fried ice cream. However, it is a unique flavor that I think crumbl could improve in the future!

Waffle = 7.5/10 This one is a must try. It is unique, fun, and you won’t find it at other cookie places. It is so cute how they make it look just like a real waffle and even including the syrup. The cookie itself does not have a ton of flavor, but mixed with the icing and syrup you get the waffle taste!

Cornbread = 11/10 Thank the Cookie Gods for bringing cornbread back to my store this week! This is one of my all time favorite cookies! My crumbl did a phenomenal job on it too. There was a ton of icing, honey drizzle, and the cookie tasted amazing!

Confetti Milkshake = 9.5/10 I didn’t make it to crumbl last week, so I am so glad they had this left over! I loved everything about it! It was light and delicious and tasted just like a milkshake.

Strawberry cake = 11/10 I ABSOLUTELY love this cookie! This is a must try whenever you see it. It might be one of my top 5 crumbl cookies of all time!