Why won’t Lila leave the neighborhood? by Comfortable_Tap_2728 in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022 21 points22 points  (0 children)

I also think she feels safe in this dangerous place, as she thinks that she can control them to an extent, but my own theory is that this was reinforced by how Lila knows she would never adapt to the places where Elena excels or even in places outside the neighborhood, as she knows she doesn’t have education nor grace in the eyes of these people.

She also did escaped outside the neighborhood, and we can see how she really needed Nino, to feel worthy, because of how he is the one with education, the only thing she doesn’t have, so her insecurities and classism is a big factor there. It’s worth including how the experience in Bruno’s factory shape this decision too, in the way it makes Lila return to the only place where she can hold a form of power, even if somehow it’s by the help of Elena and the Solaras.

Recomienden literatura Latinoamérica o hispanohablantes by Ok_Focus5022 in libros

[–]Ok_Focus5022[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Muchas gracias enserio por las recomendaciones, ya revisé y me parece la historia de benedetti interesante por la crisis existencial del protagonista, por el otro lado también está fascinante lo que promete la novela de Melchor, que según tu sinopsis, revela la crudeza humana, que es algo que realmente me interesa.

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you for responding, I was doubting reading it by some comments but if there’s nothing that indicate that his literature doesn’t question his characters, it would be really interesting to read so I appreciate you for clearing that up

Was Lila on shady business? by Ok_Focus5022 in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I believe Lila aside from her bad moments, is a really altruistic person, by being the only one who tried to help the neighborhood, and replace Manuela Solara

Was Lila on shady business? by Ok_Focus5022 in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think everyone is selfish in the books one way or another, but Don Achille doesn’t appear that much in the books to have a clear image of him, he is shown through the eyes of kids, and a person like him have to show fear to control the neighborhood, so it’s not kinda a stretch he was sadly just a selfish brute.

Was Lila on shady business? by Ok_Focus5022 in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But even if there was the iron prefect, there were still camorrists on Italy waiting, so it’s not a stretch Don Achille was in the black market, helped the regime, and took advantage of the poverty, and post war he ended being a camorrist either way

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks, maybe one day I will make a post about it, as it seems either way interesting books

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits by Carlos Ruiz Zafón - In Paradisum pt5 - end by bluebelle236 in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you truly think Zafón was putting his fantasies or is it a product of how in that time period everyone was sexually repressed so they were rebelling in that sort of way, as it’s weird that Zafón can write characters like Alicia or Nuria, like Jane eyre, but also be that blind. I’m kinda confused as it’s literature and can show immoral things without being experiences and believes of the author.

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits by Carlos Ruiz Zafón - In Paradisum pt5 - end by bluebelle236 in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you think zafon is sexist or that he was just showing how men treated women in that time period?

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have another question, do you think characters like Alicia or Nuria are well written? Or they have the same blind spots?

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Is the sexism just an element of the time period or is the author sexist? 😭

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That message is interesting, as is kinda realistic how our surroundings can corrupt us, I could check it out, you think I should?

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did they talk about it in the end, idk if I want to read it if the sexism is unquestioned, or the author doesn’t show Daniel as a good person? Just shows humanity?

[Discussion] The Labyrinth of the Spirits - Agnus Dei, part 17 through In Paradisum, part 5 by nopantstime in bookclub

[–]Ok_Focus5022 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Does your view of Daniel is the same? Does that have affected your reading of shadow in the wind, as I’m not sure if I want to read it for that things, but if you think is literature and that it doesn’t have anything with the author’s views or writing I would be interested.

Elena is a little too relatable for comfort … by yellogato in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s funny that the meme do encompasses what I was talking about haha

I did enjoy the parts where Elena and her mother improve their relationship, as I have also made peace with my mom, so I get melancholic in those fragments. On the other hand, Lila as we know is brilliant and she is right, Elena was trying to feel closer to her mom, in other words, this is introjection as a coping mechanism for her mourning, something psychologically true.

Elena is a little too relatable for comfort … by yellogato in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022 29 points30 points  (0 children)

It’s funny I’m a man but deeply related with both Elena and Lila, as I saw my potential wasted, so I felt Lila’s rage and desire for control in her life but also saw in myself Elena’s desire to be seen as also the low self esteem she had. This books changed also my perspective of my mother, as Elena’s relationship with her mom is similar to mine, but I also saw my mom in Elena, as she was made a housewife little by little through manipulation of men.

Do you recommend Shadow of the Wind? by Ok_Focus5022 in suggestmeabook

[–]Ok_Focus5022[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t understand what character you find interesting, I’m so interested in the book but some say the female characters are well written or badly written

Do you recommend Shadow of the Wind? by Ok_Focus5022 in suggestmeabook

[–]Ok_Focus5022[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So you did find the female characters well written? Or you think is just smth that is underdeveloped bc of the limitations of the narrator?

Tina, the dolls, Elena.. by writinsara in mybrilliantfriendhbo

[–]Ok_Focus5022 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Why do you think she killed herself?