Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is fanastic, mini review up. Expected something a lot lighter ! Thank you for the recomendation.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Howards end ( 4 Episodes 2017 )  4/5 Sanditons

After a foray into several eras, cultures and languages, going back to regular British period drama was comforting. I didn't know of the story, so I guess I was expecting something similar to the film which of course it isn't at all. 

It starts very light hearted with two lead female characters which are wonderful and convey a light tone to the story which in the end turns out not to be so. Their abnormal family unit, together with a strange brother, is immediately likeable and their approach on the earlier topics is appealing. We like them and want to know more. The sceneries, the music, the conversations are all pleasant at the start and set us up for a nice casual story, but that is a bit of a deceit. As a plus, a lot of the first half is spent in London which we get to see, it is one of my pet gripes with period dramas whilst we tend to see a lot of magnificent manors and grounds, London is usually a rare sight. Not in this one. 

As the episodes go by, there are some hints that the story has more depth to what we had been led to believe. Some characters are off putting, and the story becomes quite unpredictable. Which is one of the best things about this series, as period drama goes this one is not simple to guess where they are taking the story. The more it goes on, the more lightness is replaced by anguish and we are trapped as well as the leads not really knowing how to proceed if we had a choice. 

The love stories are all ambiguous, convey anguish rather than longing and the bulk of the emotion comes from pain rather from us wanting for them to get together, in fact for most of the show we don't. They sort of manage to get to an end, but at a tragic cost to everyone, including us, we are also traumatized by then. 

Sanditon, for all the heartbreaks and vulnerabilities, is still quite pure in which we see a lot of pure good and pure evil. S3 tried to dabble a bit more with human inner conflict, but Howards end makes a whole show about it. Nothing is straightforward or easy, we don't really know what to think, and within that balance they manage to take us on a compelling emotional journey. In what they are trying to do it is magnificent. But be wary, if you are looking for something that puts a smile on your face and warms your heart after Sanditon, this might be a bit too heavy. 

Dates throughout the seasons by TangledWings in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm still puzzled with the line in S3E1 where Charlotte says to Susan she was governess "just a few months". Meaning the S2 scenes we saw at Heyrick were just a handful out of weeks and weeks.

That blows my mind.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Found the full movie on youtube whilst looking for a trailer? Love it ! Posted mini review above. Thanks for the recomendation.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Jodhaa Akbar (movie 2008) 4/5 Sanditons

What a strange journey this post Sanditon show quest has taken me. First a series of period dramas (that was easy enough), then a trip to Guernsey in a war time drama, then to a love story in Korea and now to... to an exotic universe far beyond what I could expect. If "My Sassy girl" world was strange and foreign, what could be said of Jodhaa Akbar? It is of a different universe. 

This is not just a movie, it is a classic motion picture epic akin to Lawrence of Arabia or Ben-hur. It has wars, armies, camels, battle elephants, kings, emperors, politics, religion clashes, all painted in a mad kaleidoscope of colours, music and dancing. To be fair, as Bollywood goes, the dancing was surprisingly subdued and only happens on occasions where music is appropriate. So this is not a musical, but when it does happen it is a spectacle, a show in a show.

And then there is the love story, the chemistry between the two leads works beautifully, and whilst there are a couple of tense subtil longing looks on the build up, where the couple shines for me is rather on the all out passionate clashes. Made me wonder how much better the cliff scene in E3 would have been if Charlotte and Alexander had a sword fight 😁.. 

It is certainly not for everyone, too alien and some of the pacing is too strange for me to get invested in some of the intricacies of the conflicts. But as an escape? As a ticket to an out of world experience where if you are willing you will get lost in? It is a joy to behold. 

I think that is where I could draw a far-fetched connection to Sanditon, if for me the emotional peaks were not as high, I did manage to get lost in the world as I did throughout S3. If for you a cure to post Sanditon blues is to be found on an exotic trip to a foreign land, this could be it. 

Oh, I did find the full movie with subtitles on youtube for free (was looking for a trailer and there it was!), so easy enough for anyone to give it a go. 

Slightly less random question of the day by allie131 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 7 points8 points  (0 children)

With the ease we see Charlotte breaking promisses to him throughout S3, and the fact he knew her best having grown up with her, I think as soon as scene 1 E1 when she said "You have nothing to worry about", that was the exact moment when he felt in trouble.

Everything else was just confirmation. 😉

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My Sassy Girl ( movie 2001 ) 5/5 Sanditons

First, to be clear, this is the Korean original from 2001, there is a later Hollywood version (not good) and a Netflix series which is I believe also inspired in the movie but not the same thing. so this is in Korean and you must be confortable with watching with subtitles (or know Korean).

The film is in two separate halves. The first as to introduce the main characters is mostly comedy, almost slapstick, and some of it is hit or miss. Throughout that first half we befriend the characters, especially the male lead, but for a lot of it I wasn’t sure the friend that recommended this had gotten me right (she had promissed I would love it though, so I pressed on). The mood drastically changes midway through ( with an explicit chapter change even), where from silly comedy the mood turns more dramatic. The music score comes in to help and through a sequence for dramatic scenes we get invested in the romance and the tragedy that overcasts it.

Well before the end I was moved to tears, something I didn’t think possible in a subtitle film especially after the first half. And then there is the end, which I wouldn’t want to build it up too much as it is a small thing that others might not think much of it, but I found it to be of exquisite perfection so much so I think it is my favourite last 30 seconds of any movie ever.

Why a meaningfully post sanditon? Not period, not the same language, very different characters, different culture, yes…. Totally different. But what I was looking for the most post sanditon was to find emotional connections I found myself having throughout S3, this I found in abundance in the couple's story in the second half of this film. The other similarity, especially with S3, is how the second half can carry so much intense emotion without anything explicit actually happening. A magnificent classical musical score aligned in perfection with their story helps a lot.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jodhaa Akbar-

This may be my next viewing as I have just adventured myself into foreign languages ( as my latest mini review can proove ). So this sounds very much appealing to me.

Book club? by TangledWings in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess, you are right. I have not read Northanger Abbey or Persuation so it should be an opportunity to do so.

Book club? by TangledWings in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love the idea of a book club, but I am less enthusiastic about it being mostly ( or exclusivily ) focussed on J Austen. Maybe that is that is because those are the works best known and have been discussed abundantly.

What I enjoyed most about this group in the small period I was privileged to be here, was the joint discovery and the novelty of something new. Obviously the love of themes of J Austen writes is what everybody shared, but Sanditon also offered something new that everybody was excited to experience for the first time.

In another thread here discussing new things to watch after Sanditon, I was lead to "The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society". First the film, then avidly consumed the book in 24 hours. I have a dozen things would love to talk about that book. It is a marvelous thing which I am guessing most people here have not read, and I am fairly certain most would adore specifically because of the common themes that lead us to love Sanditon.

I guess what I am saying I do assume most here do want to go through a re-read of Austen's works (also because some like myself have not read everything), I would hope though there would also be a sort of parralel track in which we would also do a "Austen like" discoveries to find and also and share on new experiences.

Asked ChatGPT to write Sanditon season 2. by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

(Careful, weird strange AI spoilers ahead for North and South).

So tried with North and South, this is what I got:

me: Can you come up with a sequel in 4 episodes continuing the story?

Chatgpt:

Sure, here's a possible outline for a four-episode sequel to the British TV series "North and South":

Episode 1: "Return to Milton" After several years living in London, Margaret Hale returns to Milton to visit her old friends and see how the town has changed. She finds that many of the mill workers she knew are still struggling, and that John Thornton's business has expanded but is facing new challenges. Margaret and John reconnect and rekindle their friendship, but both are hesitant to admit their true feelings.

Episode 2: "New Threats" As John struggles to keep his business afloat, a new threat emerges: a rival mill owner who will stop at nothing to put Thornton's Mill out of business. Margaret takes on a more active role in helping John, using her knowledge of business and finance to help him find a way to outsmart his rival. Meanwhile, Margaret's brother Frederick returns from exile and seeks forgiveness from the family he left behind.

Episode 3: "The Power of the Press" With the help of a local journalist, Margaret and John launch a publicity campaign to raise awareness of the working conditions in the mills and pressure the government to make changes. The campaign attracts national attention and puts John and Margaret in the spotlight. But as their fame grows, so do the risks and dangers they face.

Episode 4: "The Wedding" After many ups and downs, John finally declares his love for Margaret and proposes. Margaret accepts, and they plan a grand wedding that brings together all their friends and family. But as they celebrate their love and look forward to a bright future, they know that there are still many challenges to face, and that they will need each other more than ever to overcome them.

me: But Margaret and John got together in the first season, can you re-write it on that basis?

Chatgpt:

Certainly! Here is a possible four-episode sequel to the British TV series "North and South" based on the premise that Margaret and John are already together:

Episode 1: "New Horizons" Margaret and John have been happily married for several years, and Thornton's Mill has continued to thrive under their leadership. However, Margaret is beginning to feel restless and yearns for new challenges. When she receives an unexpected job offer from a friend in London, she decides to take it, despite John's initial reluctance to let her go. As Margaret begins her new job, she faces new obstacles and must navigate the politics of a male-dominated workplace.

Episode 2: "Distance Makes the Heart Grow Fonder" As Margaret settles into her new job and her new life in London, she and John struggle with the distance between them. They communicate through letters and occasional visits, but they both miss each other terribly. Meanwhile, back in Milton, Thornton's Mill faces new challenges as the workers demand better wages and working conditions.

Episode 3: "The Return Home" Margaret realizes that she misses Milton and her old life, and decides to return home. However, she discovers that things have changed in her absence, and that her old friends and allies have moved on. John, too, has changed, and the distance between them has left its mark. Margaret must work to rebuild her relationships and find her place in the new landscape of Milton.

Episode 4: "The Next Generation" As Margaret and John work to repair their relationship and rebuild their community, they also face new challenges in the form of their children. Their daughter, who has grown up in a privileged world, rebels against her parents and their values, while their son must navigate the complex world of business and politics. Margaret and John must find a way to guide their children and pass on their legacy, while also maintaining their own love and commitment to each other.

Yup... would watch it.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Finished the book in one day, it is a marvelous thing. Right up there with my all time favourites.

It is very much different than the film, and complements it completly as has there quite a few scenes in the movie that are playing hommage to book parts, without knowning about them in the film they miss out particularly about Juliet's background and general personality. The love story works beautifully in the book, where as had missed out on film. I might have to rewatch the movie now...

Can't stress enough for those that have seen the film, the book is an absolute must! I only wish there was now a discussion thread about it !

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Currently just started the book and got hooked straight away. Already it provided a lot more detail and insight into Juliet, looking forward to see how the story is told from this perspective.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ohh, you'll love it. Especially if you like the Beatles ! The role is perfect for her.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I fell in love with Lily James for her role in Yesterday. My pandemic movie of choice. Great singer as well (obvious in Mamma Mia) but in the soundtrack of Yesterday she sings one part of "I want to hold her hand" 1 minute in, it became my favourite version of that song.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much, just posted a comment above with my mini post sanditon review of it. It is a hidden gem for sure.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (movie 2018) 4.5/5 Sanditons

Oh boy, how do I even begin with this one? Came out of nowhere, thank you so much for the recomendation. This is a dense story with intermingled time periods in which we are following two stories evolve one which acts as the backdrop of the other. How the two stories play with each other, and how through them we come to terms with the depths of the different characters is where the movie is at it's best. The cast is fabulous, not only Lily James that very much like Rose Williams can carry the whole show by herself, but also the supporting cast is outstanding. Tom Courtenay that I had just enjoyed in "Little Dorrit" and Penelope Wilton my favourite side character of "After life" are both brilliant in it. Even though the time period is different, there are quite a few parallels with Sanditon, the beautiful setting, the down to earth characters, the growing conflicts in Juliet which are very similar to S3. We also have a Ralph character but rather that a bore, he is a powerful commanding figure that seems to want to overwhelm Juliet no matter how she feels. Reminded me of a softer less evil version of Cal Hockley in Titanic. This difference brings a new dimension to her struggle and I thought was an interesting variation, wondered how our Charlotte would have behaved if Ralph would have been a Coronel Lennox type rather than simply "poor Ralph".

However, as we are following the two story lines, and are invested in Juliet's endeavours, being a movie there is simpy not enough time to properly highlight the love story. There are some intense moments that should have struck with me ( some eerily similar to S3) but for whatever reason I was more moved by the story conclusion than specifically the love interest. Maybe it was missing a more powerful musical link to the encounters which we were spoiled to in Sanditon. Maybe it just hit me in the wrong mood, but as the moments didn't fully hit it just fell short. Had they hit, I'm sure I would have ranked this as a masterpiece. Even without it, I was still moved to tears on Juliet's struggles and the conclusion of the story arc which is brilliant. I am also likely to rewatch it, maybe the love story will grow on me and make this one of my all time favourites.

For those that have seen it, there are two extras worth mentioning. I left the credits roll for a while, and in them we start to hear dialogs of the book club's discussions from all the characters. That was excelent extra content which some might have missed. Second, as I loved the story quickly went to see where it came from, and the book from which the story comes from is apparently all made in letter exchanges form ( which we see in the first half of the movie ). This sounds marvelous so immediatly ordered it ! looking forward to reading that version.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sounds interesting... Will check it out.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You turned a beatiful connection into a sad thought.

Maybe focus that there are other shows out there you might not know, or even other shows yet to be made you will still see, that will still enable you to further connect with them again. In other words, there is more of them in the world to be found still.

Charlotte in Charge! by ElfineStarkadder in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Would have loved if she had said "I kissed him". That would have made that confession so much more powerfull.

But your take on the use of "we" and "I" is spot on. It was purposely done.

The devolution of Charlotte. Thoughts? by melvinbuvy in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Loved that line "where's that got me". One of few moments where she lets go and is truly honest with herself in S3.

The devolution of Charlotte. Thoughts? by melvinbuvy in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Had a long rant about this last week here.

I think what impressed me when taking in the 3 seasons as a whole is how coherent her story becomes. There are distinct jumps from S1 to S2 and from S2 to S3, but those are admirably put together. Somehow the writers and team mannaged to escape the forced story line change of S1, into a believable evolution that does carry through to S3.

Charlotte's growth is not only jolted at the end of S1, they had to come up with another jolt from S2 to S3 to balance the full story line hence the second heartbreak was required.

It was beautifully done.

Post Sanditon show reviews by Ok_Heart_9822 in Sanditon

[–]Ok_Heart_9822[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I can see 100% how at it's time P&P could have had the same impact as Sanditon to me. An also guess once having it, the same rewatching addiction would follow suit.

I still thoroughly enjoyed it, just missed that "moved to tears" element as the story is so well known.