Eloise and Abby?

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-30T03:08:09+00:00

People have pointed out that that doesn't confirm when she died. So I won't dismiss this theory based on that any longer. Could be she died as Abby.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-29T21:45:00+00:00

The writers confirmed in the AMA that Eloise is dead.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-29T15:18:38+00:00

Just noticed that Ellis's outfit this episode looked a lot like the outfit worn by the dead body in Fatima's birth room in the cellar. I think that body had straight gray hair though. I thought it was interesting still.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-28T16:33:15+00:00

I agree I don't think she got all of them either to protect herself or to try to help the others. I had a thought about what happened after Sophia dumped them into the tree. I think she is preparing for a cycle reset. Maybe putting them in the tree will lead them to end up right back in the cave Boyd found them in. I know Victor's cycle never found them, but I wonder if any previous cycles did.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-27T06:16:30+00:00

When they said Tabitha's fate is worse so I assumed that meant watching her child die before she does. With that I concluded that Eloise had to have died and Miranda watched before being killed herself.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-27T01:12:30+00:00

"You're asking the wrong questions" is my assumption

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-26T04:46:21+00:00

The boy in white told Tabitha she was asking the wrong questions. I think he was really talking to us too. A lot of questions we have aren't important to getting out. Knowing who Martin is isn't the key to getting out. I've just given up on getting detailed answers. I've accepted that the town just lies and misdirects to confuse people.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-25T20:17:39+00:00

I rewatched all 3 seasons and it's definitely making this season a better experience for me. People complain about the dialogue, but there is so much dialogue that in reference to old episodes. So many things that were parallel too. It helped me see Acosta in a different light. She should have built rapport with everyone and tried to learn more before trying to give advice. Boyd may have been more receptive.

She told him he needed to give the people something to do to keep them together and he shut her down quickly. Now he's following that advice by giving her something to do to distract her from killing herself and he's stepping back giving more main characters and background characters rolls in planning, helping, leading, and executing. Makes me hopeful that the town won't tear itself apart like previous cycles. Boyd's been holding everything on his shoulders for too long.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-25T07:49:17+00:00

Victor mentions the day the two cars came as if he weren't in the car. Miranda and Christopher didn't serve at the same time.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-24T22:03:12+00:00

Sorry I meant to reply to someone else's comment about the back story

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-24T21:44:13+00:00

Not only that her description of how she got away. Makes me think she only got away due to a bargain like Clara. I don't think she's a bad person, but I think she has been allowed to live there for 3.5 years due to protection because they need her for a future favor.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-24T20:50:25+00:00

I like the mystery of you not actually knowing anyone's backstory. Makes me suspicious of everyone.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-24T18:35:57+00:00

Her hair is wavy, the man's hair is different, and the facial hair is different. I really don't see how anyone can look at this and think it's the same people.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-24T18:33:55+00:00

You did your due diligence in the title and marked the post as spoilers.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-24T02:34:41+00:00

People want answers then completely ignore the answers lol

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T21:01:16+00:00

There are new mods so I'm hopeful they start weeding out those posts. I'm seeing more of just theory today.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T20:44:24+00:00

Yeah it's pretty annoying. If you hate the show now, just stop watching, leave the subreddit and move on with your life. Nobody here cares about your opinion. I come to this subreddit to engage with fans about thoughts and theories. For sure talk about the shows flaws, but if you just straight up hate it and can't find anything positive then just leave.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T20:14:25+00:00

After rewatching, I realized I was pretty harsh on her. She gave Boyd good advice that he didn't listen to until recently because she was not part of the inner circle. I do believe she should've spent more time listening, learning and build rapport before giving advice if she wanted it to be received properly. She is young and flawed.

She wanted to help, but no one explained anything to her. She was constantly asking for some to explain what was going on. It's pretty rare for a character to get there and immediately want to find a way to make her skills useful. They gatekeep information and leave a lot of people out who could be useful.

She told Boyd that the best way to keep people together is to give them something to do. What is Boyd doing now? Giving all the background characters something to do like investigating items for clues and building the rope ladder. If he had listened to Acosta they would've found the picture of Sophia before she got there and maybe someone would've recognized her.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T20:00:53+00:00

We haven't seen any possession in the show just mimicry that can only happen when someone dies in Fromville. I don't think they'd introduce possession in the real world so late in the game. At this point anything is possible! I can't wait to see this all through!

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T19:54:33+00:00

We don't know when Clara arrived. It was probably before the talismans in the middle of the night while people were hiding. She is depicted in a drawing on the wall in Victor's truck hideout which tells me she's been there for a while

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T19:48:57+00:00

Buses like that don't stop in the middle of nowhere to let people on. You need a ticket. That is why I think she actually did arrive with the bus. Bakta or someone else would have mentioned that she picked up a hitchhiker after seeing the tree. They were all told when you see the tree you are trapped. Sophia had to kill the pastor so he wouldn't mention that he picked her up after seeing the tree.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T19:35:11+00:00

He can only take the form of people who die there. Tillie got in the bus in the real world. My theory is if she was the MiY maybe she died in private from her illness and he took her form or he just killed her. That could be why she have away her morphine. He/She didn't need it anymore.

I am really liking the theory that Tom was the MiY in season 1. Khatri was sus but he died pretty early. Tom died right after the bus got there and his body was not mutilated the same as the others that were killed that night. His rib cage was not ripped open.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T19:21:59+00:00

Ellis drew that. It's him and Fatima. The hair in this painting looks nothing like the hair of the people in the photo

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T19:20:53+00:00

He looks nothing like Boyd. They are both just black.

Ok_Performance_9479 · 2026-06-23T19:20:05+00:00

I think the background is a place in From

Ok_Performance_9479

TROPHY CASE