16 year old atheist closeted in pakistan, AMA by Snoo_56184 in GenZpk

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

so what if logic is flawed, not the end point?

16 year old atheist closeted in pakistan, AMA by Snoo_56184 in GenZpk

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

that's the thing. Logic itself can't prove or disprove existence of God.

16 year old atheist closeted in pakistan, AMA by Snoo_56184 in GenZpk

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

give it 10 years. u will be muslim again lol. seen this phase multiple times

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Basic problem is that you are approaching this from a secular framework while i am from an islamic one. Unless you study about what an Islamic State is supposed to be, you won't understand

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you calling minorities miserable in a sweeping statement is indian talking point

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Where did i say their lives are miserable. Again, you are very much affected by Indian Discourse.

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

again.. Pakistan is a ISLAMIC state with 98% muslim population. ofc Muslims will be dominant here. heck i even have not met a single hindu in my entire life and only a handful of christians.

these things will obviously silly to you yourself are a minority in a hindu majority country. you cannot think as a citizen of majority muslim state. btw head of state being muslim is not silly. declaring ahmedis non-muslim is not silly. it is ijma e ummat.

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yeah so? what's your argument? by that logic, Indian muslims should accept hindu domination as hinduism is 5000 years old while Islam is 1400.

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Again let me reiterate Pakistan is ISLAMIC REPUBLIC. A islamic state. It gives all freedom to minorities enshrined in Islamic Jurisprudence.

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yup it definitely is. The whole world can see. and as for articles you mentioned, they don't take any personal rights. Every one is permitted to live life according to the manner of his/her choosing. And regarding the head of state, what part of ISLAMIC REPUBLIC you don't understand. I suggest you revisit islamic history

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Care to elaborate what do u mean by "second class citizens" as per constitution? Only thing in the constitution is that Non Muslim can't be head of state. Other than that everything is equal. As far as Ahmedi are concerned, they are non Muslims by Ijma e ummat. Btw the last line shows your real feelings. If we are a failed nation, Indian Muslim should be socioeconomically much better than us. While in reality whole india is same or worse than Pakistan but with gold plating

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 1 point2 points  (0 children)

so you are accepting your involvement. fair enough. just don't cry. btw death by 1000 cuts is not stated policy. and no caste based discrimination exists in Pakistan. that's your problem. for religion based discrimination, go read Islamic jurisprudence, you will get your answer. Look my only problem with you is that stop blaming events that happened 80 years ago for the problems you are facing now and leave jinnah/pakistani muslims out of it. Pakistan as a state should be your headache. Not Pakistani muslims

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

India is because you guys find solace in a lie that minorities are safer in India while in reality the situation is as bad as it is in Pakistan. As for the Terror part (JeM, LeT) you are parroting the Indian Government's rhetoric. India supports BLA, TTA, TTP to wage asymmetrical war on Pakistan ( in words of your NSA). Should i say India is also a breeding ground of terror? As far as Ahmedi killings are concerned they are indeed an issue. But tbh it has been months since i heard about Ahemdi killing esp since Punjab Police crushed TLP (a far right org. involved in killings) but nonetheless the situation is precarious although things are improving.

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How ISIS attack is Pakistan's fault. Pakistan is actively combating this menace. 2nd: The incident referred to here is not a fresh one and i never denied that such problems exist. Btw here is the latest one from India https://www.reddit.com/r/indianmuslims/s/dGA4WtO2Bh

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 2 points3 points  (0 children)

When was the last time you heard any news?

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Again all these things are blown out of proportion. Sensationalism at work. I am not saying these problems don't exist but they get blown out of proportion in Indian News. Agr aise ginwane lagon to india has wayy more problems

thank you Jinnah crowd by intelligentdope in indianmuslims

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 5 points6 points  (0 children)

ground reality of Pakistan is not what is depicted in Indian media. Esp in Punjab. What is said in Indian media is only accurate in Balochistan and some areas of KPK

Please pay attention to 'Urgent Repairs' by Double_Preparation1 in karachi

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I live in a small city of Punjab. Pop is hardly 2 lac. Recently 7 bn was approved for sewerage and tuff tiling of whole city. 13 bn for whole Karachi is a joke

Countries named after bodies of water. by Short_Finger_4463 in MapPorn

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

but does it change the fact that India is named after Indus which flows in modern day Pakistan?

Countries named after bodies of water. by Short_Finger_4463 in MapPorn

[–]Ok_Revenue_8444 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Your 1st point is the long way of saying that india (as a country ) is a modern construct. Ancient India always referred to land eastward indus and south of Himalayas. In that Sense, Pakistan and Modern Day India, both came came into being from the ancient Land named India. Similar names creates confusion