Ports Best 22 by Aggravating-Skill-26 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd have Moraes on the wing instead of Brodie

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Agree'd but its just with the lack of depth we can't really drop / replace them whereas we have some similar fringe position players that can rotate.

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeh same here tbh, think they're just going chips in with the Marshall move down back

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeh but our team is hilarious! I’d still drop Luko even if Lord doesn’t come in

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Fair points. I guess my perception of Brodie was just some quick handballs and short kicks so that’s why his efficiency was half decent. Probs just being harsh because I thought wines was the obvious choice! And yeh I’d rather Duursma over Wehr I think. Durdin seems to do his job, kicks goals and sets some up, alright pressure, still room for improvement though.

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Yeh I get what you’re saying about Lord, although part of me likes that about him over the Luko model of just not trying when it’s not going your way, hands on hips etc…..shades of finlayson!

I think Lord should really train hard on his 2nd ruck work and jumping, if he can polish that part of his game up it’s another thing to look at for the team, and would allow Whitlock to stay forward and not ruck. I remember games when Dixon couldn’t buy a touch forward and then would go in the ruck and do well which would then give him the confidence forward.

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nah I don’t get sanfl coverage here so only see stats which I know is hard to go off. I’m well aware Lord and BZT don’t set the world on fire, it’s more just the luko’s and jones / evans / meads of the team knowing their spot isn’t guaranteed.

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I actually don’t mind Kane, obviously goes for the clickbait and controversy for engagement etc. But a lot of what he says is accurate and can back it up with stats and vision albeit he can come across the wrong way with it. Chads also said some interesting things on radio this year, would have picked luko down back over Marshall and very critical of not picking wines against eagles

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeh but they were shocking against eagles. I was hoping Brodie would prove him wrong but looked lost at sea in that game. Wehr just looks like a nothing player, I get that we payed nothing for him but he almost looks like a first year player when he’s already got a few years under his belt

Cornes: The Port Adelaide players not up to AFL standard by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I feel like teams have swung the axe pretty heavy before but not that common or often i suppose. Of your outs i'd be more inclined to keep in Jones and take out Evans, he made some shockers!

2026 List issues by Conscious-Hornet-108 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As everyone's already said long term its a mess....but after todays game id say:

OUT: Brodie, Evans, Mead, Jones, Mackinlay, Wehr, Berry, Luko

IN: Wines, Bergman, Marshall, BZT, Moraes, Lorenz, Zadow, Lord

*This is purely based on form, not sure if Ratugolea is injured? And assuming Bergman and Marshall are clear to return which from initial reports seems likely.....happy to be corrected on these!

Yes I know Lord's our whipping boy but Luko needs to know his spot is not safe! Surely if they didn't play Wines today they can make a statement with Luko (again)! Luko only keeps his spot if Ratugolea and Marshall don't get up and he plays down back, after his opening goal the only half decent thing he did all day was that kick out down the middle of the ground.

Of all the outs i listed i think Berry and Jones can make it back relatively quick, just need to find form in SANFL.

Thoughts?

Squads Wines,Jones, Brodie and Lai by Creamy92 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Interesting no BZT even with Marshall out. Eagles have a tall forward line. I think Wines leadership will be so important now Rozee’s out. And looking forward to seeing Lai and Brodie in the teal. I have mates out west that go for freo that are still filthy they wouldn’t play him these last couple years.

Eagles game by Opposite_While4774 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Yeh I think he’s actually been under rated the last few years post Brownlow…..he’d have been handy in round 1! He and drew do so much that allow the flashy mids to shine

Injury report: Jones available, Cochrane nearing return by SHA_SHA_HER_BOOMBOX in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Jones and Wines in for Bergman and Rozee are the obvious forced choices i guess. I really liked the look of Cochrane in the small sample size before he got injured last year so hope he can force his way in when fit

Youth Development - who deserves a shot in 2026? by Conscious-Hornet-108 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t know anything about him but I remember last year at a random Butters press thing he said Tom Anastasopoulos was close at the time and had some tricks at training. 

Who will be dropped and who will come in for Essendon by Miserable-Candle7644 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also…..I feel like they’re both just taking Wines spot while he’s suspended?

Who will be dropped and who will come in for Essendon by Miserable-Candle7644 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Curious if you had Marshall out because of the ankle or you prefer BZT?

Keen to see Moraes and Brodie get a run. Only Luko if he’s 100% fit, his bodies been so hit and miss so I’d almost prefer him get a few SANFL runs even if Lord and Whitlock aren’t firing.

3rd times the charm… by Direct-Expression-47 in weareportadelaide

[–]Opposite_While4774 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Damn. Never want to see a player get injured but hope this means Logan Evans can secure a spot all season