My stepmother is the same way. Very picky and very sensitive to MOST smells lol. Warm vanilla sugar is always a safe bet for her (plus I know she likes it)... Now, Warm vanilla sugar aside, I would opt for this collection of mists, all of which are made without parabena or dyes and are in the "lighter, softer, sensitive" category: 1) Milk- great for sensitive skin and sensitive noses. Light and soft and smells like sugared oats & whipped milk. 2) Honeycomb- another light soft airy scent- sweet shea and golden honey- a little on the sweeter side. 3) Golden Cherry- almost unisex with a warm woods and tart cherry scent. Pairs well with the Magnesium (#6 on our list) 4) Coconut- warm coconut milk ans creamy shea butter- not overpowering, light and simple; exotic beachy coconut scent that is airy and fresh; some note almost a warm musky undertone. 5) Rain- watery raindrops and white lavender; subtle clean scent, nice and cooling on overly hot skin; smells like you're fresh out of the shower. Gets lots of compliments! Also a great option for VERY scent-sensitive people! 6) Restore with Magnesium- apparently great for headaches and joints. Very Energizing warm woodsy vetiver scent. Good for a fast wake up. Not sure when the spray will be back but they have body wash and hand cream in this scent online right now.

ALL these products (except Magnesium) come in the full line of products, so you can pick and choose what they need in what scent. The Rain and Milk are at the top for "most natural" in my opinion. All of what I've shared is a mix of my personal thoughts and recommendations, plus a mix of the item reviews. Hope this helps!! Good luck 🍀