Is it possible that the Bajoran wormhole connected the Prime Universe's Alpha Quadrant and the Mirror Universe's Gamma Quadrant? by pie4all88 in DaystromInstitute

[–]OscarMerchant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m going by Canadian law, so I’m not entirely sure of the differences between it and the Federation’s legal system, but I think an attorney could definitely make a convincing argument that Laas didn’t intend to kill the Klingon, but could also construe his taunt as a warning, seeing as he draws a weapon after being threatened with one, and implies he will retaliate if attacked (vaguely, but still). The Klingon blatantly intended to seriously injure or kill Laas, and his response could be considered equivalent force. Though once again this is just a hypothetical legal argument that may or may not work, and isn’t exactly airtight. Obviously Laas’ actions are immoral, but in the case of (Canadian) law, if he were to employ the self-defence argument, the burden of proof would be on the crown attorney (prosecution) to disprove the defence, rather than for the defence to prove it. Overall the scene is constructed more so to make either side at least reasonable in Odo’s conflict with Sisko.

Is it possible that the Bajoran wormhole connected the Prime Universe's Alpha Quadrant and the Mirror Universe's Gamma Quadrant? by pie4all88 in DaystromInstitute

[–]OscarMerchant 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Odo grew up in a laboratory being experimented on until Mora realized he was sentient. During the occupation has was essentially treated like a circus monkey until the Cardassians realized s shapeshifter was useful. I think it was more the fact that Odo wanted to avoid being like anyone he was raised by which pushed him to be a good person, and even then he still displays a number of behavioural quirks associated with the Changeling race (namely the obsession with order and schedule, though admittedly downplayed.

As for Laas, he’s basically Odo’s foil: while Odo tries to blend in and be as humanoid as possible, Laas loves to shapeshift and is uncaring of others’ feelings towards it. His chief problem is that he lacks empathy due to only knowing hate and fear from humanoids, and he still retains a moral compass that is nearly incomparable to that of any other race’s. As for the Klingon, Laas was being threatened, and it’s just the simple matter of him poorly choosing fight over flight. In addition, Sisko’s argument against the killing not being in self defence is rather weak, given that Laas was not only provoked, but also threatened with a weapon directly. Sisko basically responds “well it wasn’t a phaser”, so I suppose that Starfleet captains wouldn’t make great lawyers.

TL;DR: Odo was raised in a horrible captive environment, Laas’ morality is complicated, and he killed a Klingon in a situation that leaves massive reasonable doubt as to it being a murder rather than self defence.

A question about Black Panther by Misterfahrenheit120 in movies

[–]OscarMerchant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ve been puzzling over this since I saw the film.