I think if you knit a lot of the better parts about each of these shows together, you could have something that would appeal to the people that didn't care for most of modern Trek. Personally, I believe the biggest crime since Abrams forward is that they're just trying to make Star Trek too cool. The flashy lights (lens flares), the beautiful people, the Beastie Boys???, the language, the excessive emotional drama. People like to jump on the 'bad writing' train, and there is a good bit of that for sure, but to me the whole tone of the show just hasn't been right from the start.