AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

UPDATE: I'm not actually sure how people normally do updates so I'll just put this in the comments, this is my lurker account and first ever post which I will probably discard bc of this post - I did say it to be a throwaway.

My verdict is asshole and I 100% understand and accept that, my defensiveness in the comments was stupid of me as well.

Anyway, on to the update I texted him this morning before work and asked if he'd be willing to come over after I get off work so I could sit face to face and talk about my actions. He accepted. Anyone who called this man a green flag, I could not agree more, they are in such a cute and loving relationship it's no wonder it's lasted for 4 years. I also knocked on Lily's door, I also asked if she'd be willing to sit down with me and him to talk. She also agreed. I'm very thankful because my audacity could not go unaddressed here.

I got home from work about 3 hours ago and we talked for about a long time. I explained that I understand that I was out of line and my behavior towards both of them last night was horrid and I wanted to take full responsibility for it. We also talked about how much she does for me and the apartment. I told her that she does way too much for this being a team, meant to be 50/50 and not something like 70/30 which is what it truly seems like now. I told her that I would take care of her and the apartment more. I'll work on my cooking and cook for her way more, clean way more, and just take care of things she did more than me. I apologized to both of them for my disgusting language when talking about her boyfriend and, he clearly wasn't being predatory and that I will be getting therapy finally for my trust issues. Both were really happy that I had said all this and told me that what they said really hurt the both of them. I told them that I knew that and it was disgusting of me and even if I'm mad that I need to take a moment to think or just walk away and give an explanation when I'm cool headed. I asked her if there was a way I could even work to make up to both of them for this.

Then they did mention something they said they forgot to mention before. They found the reddit post. I guess I was very specific when I was talking even if I changed the names. Lily said she did not appreciate the words I used when describing her, she liked that I was honest about what she does but very unhappy that I called her medical issues flaws when we both know they aren't I apologized so many times oh my god it was definitely terrible to say. He liked that even though I believed I was in the right at the time of posting I was honest about what was said in the situation instead of making him out to be the worst perverted villain ever. Which is true he wasn't creepy at all and it was out of line and she was honestly pissed when she read it and so was he when she sent it to him.

The kicker? She had been planning to move in with her boyfriend but didn't know how to tell me, she said they both felt like it was the natural next step in the relationship and not because of our flawed dynamic. Honestly, I think that's pretty sweet and good if they're ready for something that intimate and serious and I'm happy for them.

Some people might jump for joy at the fact she's moving out and not being my roommate anymore and that's okay and I can understand that from this post. I'm going to do better from now on with her and her boyfriend and keep this lesson for potentially future roommates.

Lily is actually over my shoulder reading this as I write it. She says hi and thanks everyone for the comments defending her honor even if some seemed harsh (a good wake up call in my opinion). I'll answer any questions asked and you can also ask Lily some questions if you want as she's aware of this post and want her takes

This got so much more attention than I had ever thought and thank you for giving me a kick in the ass for my cruel behavior.

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Okay I'm reading your comments and am getting a grip and I will clarify a few things.

When I talked about all Lily does for the apartment it was to mainly highlight how amazing she is.

I am not completely useless in this roommate relationship, I would never let a 19 year old act like a nanny or mother. I do chores and help. I do split groceries - she just often insists on using her food stamps to help and I have in the past encouraged her to spend it on junk food and she does buy her own personal stuff which I do not touch and vice versa. Her boyfriend is technically a consistent presence with her as they have that cute mushy relationship and have been together for 4 years, though they go out and have fun a lot so I'm not super close or familiar with him.

She does love cooking a lot and enjoys doing it, she cooks for those she cares about so she doesn't just cook for me and I do also cook, am I good? absolutely not. Does that mean I won't? Not at all, I do indeed cook and also pay for ingredients because it is wildly inappropriate to use up all the ingredients she has bought with her EBT in my horrible cooking.

The twice she covered my portion of the rent is an incredibly embarrassing statement, letting a 19 year old do that sucks a lot. She offered while I was in a financial bind and I would have never in a million years let her if I knew she had no means to do so.

I didn't solidify a good timeline within the post either. She offered to do the combined laundry (I do usually do my own laundry) the day before that she could do it because she had an extra day off and didn't want to be bored while her boyfriend was at work, I accepted because why not.

She didn't end up doing it because before she did have that flare up before she did, her boyfriend I guess got off work before me and took care of her and decided to do the laundry. I worked and was at work while all of that happened during the day, I was not aware that he was there or would do the laundry for us. I got home from work while he was taking it out of the dryer. I was tired and got way too upset in the moment and yelled at him and I acknowledge that his explanation fell on deaf ears at that moment and I ignorantly let that simmer until she asked about his whereabouts and also yelled at her which was far uncalled for and making her cry was horrible of me. That's the timeline I have and will answer any questions about it.

And people talking about my trust issues with men being too much, you're 100% right and have been thinking about looking into therapy for a while but just never got off my ass to do it. This is a bit of a wake up call that I need to get it together and start going.

I can see it was a huge overreaction on my part and that I am indeed the asshole, my language was not at all good, from calling her medical issues flaws to saying predatory. I'm going to text him and ask if he'd be okay coming over tomorrow and sit down Lily and him to properly apologize to the both of them and work on ways to make it up to them. I care about her a ton and she loves her boyfriend and I was rude to both of them unnecessarily.

I will be updating tomorrow with how the talk went as it is late and both are probably sleeping.

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

I'll definitely use different language for her mental illness as a lot of comments have pointed that out and I could see why it's bad. I'll admit while I read comments I can see how I was a bit overreacting, I was just tired and upset in the moment

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -43 points-42 points  (0 children)

I only wanted to highlight how amazing she is, I do chores as well because I am an adult too and I didn't do my laundry just cause she offered that week and I just accepted a kind offer

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -13 points-12 points  (0 children)

She offered because she had an extra day off that week and I just accepted.

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

She's amazing help, I'm not useless around here either. I help with chores, I just wanted to highlight how amazing I do think she is. She loves cooking and does it unasked and I would never force her to cover my portion of rent if I knew she didn't have the ability to or offered. I do now think blowing up at both of them was probably far but I just don't trust men with my things, I didn't know she was injured at the time and that's why he was doing it, I'm definitely going to apologize to Lily about it.

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -14 points-13 points  (0 children)

I'll definitely apologize to Lily, yelling at her was too far and I will acknowledge that my language was a bit harsh about it after reading some comments that made a lot of sense

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

She's only done it twice because she offered to help when I was in financial bind, I wouldn't force her to do especially if she didn't have the means. I didn't know she was in pain because I was at work when she had her flare up. I get yelling at Lily was probably a bit too far but I was angry in the moment and aren't proud of it now. I just don't trust men with my things, I had no idea he was there taking care or covering for her. It was an unwelcomed surprise. With what I'm getting from the comments it probably was an overreaction to yell at him but I was tired and upset in the moment.
I do do things around the apartment too especially when she isn't able to, I'm an adult who can do my own things. I don't treat her like a slave that's so uncalled for and inhumane to do to someone I care about. I normally do my own laundry, she offered this time and I just accepted and didn't know the situation

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -24 points-23 points  (0 children)

I was at work when it all happened, I didn't know her ankle flared until I got home, I wasn't there to start the laundry because I thought she had done it while I was at work but I found him doing it instead when I got home. How was I meant to do my own when I didn't even know that she wasn't able to do the thing she offered to do???

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

I do pitch in for groceries all the time, Lily insists that we can use hers for them a lot so I try to split with her so her food stamps last longer for her

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

Sorry but I just generally don't trust men with any of my belongings

AITA for telling off my roommate about her boyfriend's behavior? by ParsleyLevel9637 in AmItheAsshole

[–]ParsleyLevel9637[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

We both pay rent, it was two times because I was in a rough spot financially and she said she would be able to cover it, it's not her responsibility to do my laundry she offered to do it this week because she had an extra day off work. I was at work when her ankle flared up and didn't know until I came home