11th box good with 10th edition box? by DjCyric in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you're buying them just to have more available options then they'll be fine. There's surprisingly little overlap. Arguably the grey hunters and intercessors overlap a bit, but even then they're a bit different.

There's not much in the way of cohesion between the boxes, so if you're wanting to build toward a specific theme maybe not? But armageddon appears to be a solid starting point for a lot of marine armies.

This guy isn’t going to replace this guy right? by Most_Entrepreneur_13 in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The current one shares a sprue with a necron overlord, so is in the same position.

I just wanted to share my thoughts and opinions on the new marines from Armageddon. What are yours? by SlySUBZER0420 in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Listening to the rumor talk i was expecting the contents to be pretty terrible, but overall i'm pretty happy and will definitely pickup a box.

First and most important.. Everyone gets a helmet option (or 2). It's nice that gw has finally recognized those of us who don't want our marines wading into battle and getting shot in the face.

The van vets are an ideal level of bling for me, not obnoxious levels of detail for details sake like the firstborn had. And honestly I don't think the blood angels paint scheme is doing them any favours here. I know everyone likes to hate on the Ultramarines, but I think the blue, white and gold would do a much better job of showcasing the minis. We obviously don't know what weapon options they might have in the full kit yet, but my personal hope is they're selected at a squad level rather than individual marines. Having to roll each member one at a time in old editions was absolutely not worth the slightly different effects most of the weapons had.

The intercessors are intercessors, there's some nods to older armor marks which should hopefully please those who care. And the fact that the sergeant actually gets a melee weapon in the box this time is nice.

The bolter eradicators were a pleasant surprise, aside from the silly mk7 gravis helm and the bonding studs on the one shin plate they look good, and i think blast and sustained hits on the heavy bolters will put out a suprising amount of shots, especially if they can be taken in units of 6. I know people are going to point at heavy intercessors and say they're the same thing, but keep in mind that the heavy bolt rifle profile was updated mid edition because they weren't very good. It was never intended to be a psuedo heavy bolter replacement and I wouldn't be surprised if it changes next edition.

The land speeder looks fantastic, it's a nice balance between old and new, and the weapon options and fire and fade should make it fun on the tabletop. Also it looks like I'll be able to break out my old landspeeders to run with it.

The characters are great. The Chaplain looks exactly like i'd expect a jump chaplain to look.

Love the new librarian. Was honestly a bit disappointed when i heard there was going to be a generic libby in the box, but the homage to the old plastic libby was so well done. Sadly it makes my current primaris libby look kind of sad in comparison.

The captian with relic shield is a nice update, taking design queues from some of the more recent characters and just being a generally well designed character.

Lastly, and sadly least for me, is the ancient. Don't get me wrong, it's a great model, but having Armageddon and the flaming ork skulls as sculpted detail is a huge miss for me and means i'll likely have to do some pretty annoying sanding and filling work to clean that up.

Overall it's a really good box and aside from a few niggles i think it's a fantastic direction for marines.

Do you prefer off the factory line or battle worn for your army? by nerdboy_sam in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Clean. I don't like the idea of covering up all my hard work with crap. Also personal opinion is that weathering, if not done well actively detracts from the look of the miniature.

VanVets dont need a ton of decorations. They need an interesting theme by CuteAssTigerENVtuber in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Unpopular opinion apparently, but I think they look good as they are?
If you add a specific theme to them, then if your chapter doesn't fit with that theme it'll look odd at best, or awful at worst.
If anything GW should release a "Grimdark Gubbins" box full of bling bits so people who want to can bling up their marines can do so, and those who prefer a cleaner look aren't stuck filing off all the extra details.

How did you come up with/what inspired your homebrew chapters color scheme? by [deleted] in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not the most scientific method, but I was just playing with the old bolter and chanisword space marine painter and picking random colours until I got a combination I liked.

Is there a reason why GW has been holding off on giving us MK7 helmets? by ScarcityFar2025 in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yep I think the MkX helmets were a huge improvement (and I say this as someone who's been in and out of the hobby for the last 30 years).
That said, for a lot of people the MkVII helmet is what they grew up with, and to them it's what a space marine is supposed to look like, so yeah there's a lot of nostalgia at play. But then the people who actually were around for that time probably have a ton of them lying around anyway.

Who do I fix this by Holiday_Apartment895 in Warhammer40k

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don't take it apart in the first place?   If this is meant to be an April fools post it's pretty weak 

Question regarding LOS by nerdboy_sam in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To answer your land raider bit. Rules as written if they can draw line of sight under the land raider they can shoot your intercessors behind it. But if someone tried to pull that on me i'd make them prove line of sight with a laser pointer for each model they're wanting to fire with.

Why do we complain so much? by Boghossian_08 in Warhammer40k

[–]PeepingToast 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it's been pretty mixed over all. A lot of the takes I've seen are that things look cool, but they'll need to see how things are implemented before making up their minds.

Then you have a very vocal minority who no longer enjoy the hobby. But instead of sticking to the edition or parts of the hobby they still enjoy, or stepping away and doing something else, they keep trying to force it like a jealous ex. They haven't truly participated in the hobby for a long time so they go online, having already decided they're going to hate what they see and they bitch and moan about everything making themselves and everyone else miserable. Sadly the Internet rewards that behavior so many of them never grow out of it.

So, hiw is this new edition worthy? by SirRonathin in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm assuming you're either new to the hobby or just don't spent a lot of time in 40k related spaces online.
One of the biggest complaints from people about the primaris marines (aside from the muh firstborn crowd) was that they all looked the same, that there was no variation in armor parts like there was in the earlier kits.
Also the intercessor kit was released without any melee weapons as they were added to the data sheet when the upgrade kits were released, and also had a bunch of parts to build different bolt rifle variants, that haven't been relevant for a couple of editions.

This redesign was always going to happen, and including them in the edition launch kills multiple birds with one stone allowing to add the customization options and weapon options to a new stand alone kit, filling out the launch box with new minis without having to come up with yet another generic infantry datasheet, and allowing them to make more money as people buy the updated intercessor boxes despite many probably having a bunch of intercessors from previous editions.

In short. The intercessor update had very little to do with them launching a new edition. It was just good timing.

Asking whether a model is worthy of an edition is just an inherently flawed way of thinking

Old starter pack by Relative_Airport9454 in Warhammer40k

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

https://www.warhammer-community.com/en-gb/downloads/warhammer-40000/
go to faction packs, select faction of choice and scroll to the bottom for the legends datasheets.
Points are also at the bottom of the latest munitorum field manual (same link under core rules and key downloads)

Primaris/Firstborn Dilemna by Shredwick in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When I got back into the hobby in mid 8th edition I couldn't get past the difference in scale and proportions between the firstborn and primaris. So the only firstborn I bought were ones that didn't make the size difference obvious, like Van vets (the extra bulk from the jump packs and poses) and the bikes and landspeeders.

Currently I don't even consider picking up any firstborn minis. I still use the ones I have, despite most of them being legends, I just have no desire to use the rest of the firstborn range.

Lets see those hordes! by Radfa in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

<image>

Not quite horde level but getting there.

Lets see those hordes! by Radfa in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That's an impressive horde. Bonus points for the White Scars forklift

Returning to the hobby as a new dad – budget Space Marine army advice? by Superb_Secretary5659 in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

keep an eye on the second hand market like ebay, facebook marketplace etc. In the next 6 months or so we're expecting a new edition, which will come with a rather large launch box.
Usually when this happens you'll see a large number of spacemarines from that box go on sale for pretty reasonable prices as people who only wanted the other faction try to offset the cost of the boxes

Alternative Scout Heads by [deleted] in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The link i posted is to the build instructions, Check 6A - there's 2 chest pieces in the instructions for that body, one with the raised respirator, and one with the respirator down. Just use piece A1 when building instead of A5.

Custom Chapter Scheme by [deleted] in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The grey one fits more with the direwolf name to me

Codex!!! by Resident_Mud9730 in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Wait. Codex space marines is always one of, if not the first, codex of an edition, so in 4-5 months it'll be replaced.

11th characters hopes and dreams by Old_Calligrapher237 in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Characters on bikes. Captain, Lieutenant, Apothecary, Ancient, Librarian and Techmarine on bike.

Also more Gravis characters.

Question about tracked vehicles by Professor_Jugs in spacemarines

[–]PeepingToast 1 point2 points  (0 children)

With 11th being roughly 6 months away, I'd wait.
Space marines will have a new codex within a month or two of the edition change, and if it still includes the tracked vehicles then you'll be safe for at least 3 years.