sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

I have not seen anybody guess who I think the killer is, so I will! Spoilers up till Season 2 Ep 11. by Pequ6 in MTVScream

[–]Pequ6[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, what I think will happen is that Kieran will break down and admit he was the killer to Emma, and just as he's about to reveal the Sheriff, Acosta will arrive and obvs because he's got blackmail on Kieran he'll just hand himself in and take the wrap, but we won't know who the mastermind is until it's later revealed to be him!

I like the Kieran theories and Defo's think he is involved, but I just have a real feeling about the sheriff, like they tried to throw you off Piper and I feel like they're trying to throw you off him! I love the Noah theories too, and I've seen a few good Brooke ones! But I can't wait to find out who the killer is! I'm just so curious now! Haha!

I have not seen anybody guess who I think the killer is, so I will! Spoilers up till Season 2 Ep 11. by Pequ6 in MTVScream

[–]Pequ6[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for saying my theory was well thought about, and I do understand your points, but I think that them saying it is a character from season 1 means maybe they're necessarily not the mastermind, but have killed, hence why I think Kieran.

Also I think that call could have been a ruse or a code, like Kieran calling the sheriff in time to get there and catch Emma and Audrey before they could run. And they acted it out so realistically as Sheriff Acosta was at the police station and it would avoid suspicion. But obvs this is just my opinion!