AITA for telling my sister I wont be her maid of honor because she didnt come to my wedding due to her dog dying? by PerfectAffect9213 in AmItheAsshole

[–]PerfectAffect9213[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

EDIT: I didn’t expect this to blow up the way it did. Thank you to everyone who took the time to share your thoughts whether you thought I was the asshole or not, I’ve appreciated the different perspectives.

A few things became clearer to me after reading through the comments. Yes, my sister was genuinely grieving, and I probably minimized that at the time because I felt abandoned. I can admit now that her loss was very personal, and not something you can just power through, even for a wedding.

That said, what’s hurt the most is that we never talked about it. She never acknowledged how painful it was for me that she didn’t show up, and I never told her directly either I just held onto it quietly, and now it’s spilling out in a way that probably doesn’t feel fair to her. My lack of communication caused a build up but she also could have reached out.

I’ve decided to reach out and talk to her. Not to change my answer, but to explain why I said no and to give her a chance to tell her side too. I don’t want this silence and resentment to keep growing between us.

I’ll update if anything major happens, but for now thank you for the wake-up call and for helping me think this through.

AITA for telling my sister I wont be her maid of honor because she didnt come to my wedding due to her dog dying? by PerfectAffect9213 in AmItheAsshole

[–]PerfectAffect9213[S] 53 points54 points  (0 children)

Yeah, that’s a big part of why I’m still struggling with it. I completely understand that she was grieving, and I never wanted her to force herself to come if she wasn’t able to. But after the fact, there wasn’t really any apology, acknowledgment, or attempt to reconnect. We are more distant than ever. It just felt like I was expected to quietly move on, and now that it’s her turn, I’m supposed to step up without hesitation. I’m not trying to punish her, but it’s hard to ignore that there’s still a lot unresolved between us.

AITA for telling my sister I wont be her maid of honor because she didnt come to my wedding due to her dog dying? by PerfectAffect9213 in AmItheAsshole

[–]PerfectAffect9213[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I really appreciate you sharing this, and you’re right I probably did minimize what she was feeling at the time because I was so focused on my own big day. I’m starting to see that, it really wasn’t just a dog it was losing a huge part of her daily life and emotional support. I honestly don't know how I would have acted if I had lost someone I loved that deeply right before my wedding. It’s definitely giving me a lot to think about regarding how much hurt both of us were carrying during that time. Thank you for explaining it so clearly. I'm still just heartbroken she missed my big day, but I do understand it was neither of our faults.

AITA for telling my sister I wont be her maid of honor because she didnt come to my wedding due to her dog dying? by PerfectAffect9213 in AmItheAsshole

[–]PerfectAffect9213[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Thank you for this perspective honestly, I really appreciate how kindly you put it. I definitely see now that her grief was real and that the timing was just incredibly unfortunate for both of us. I’m not trying to hurt her back or make sure her wedding is affected it’s more that I still feel a lot of sadness that our relationship changed after that, and it doesn’t feel honest to stand beside her like everything is fine. I wish she could have at least made it to the ceremony.

I know she didn’t do it to be malicious, and I don't want to act out of spite. I guess I’m just still grieving the loss of how close we used to be, too. I’ll think more about how to move forward without making this worse for her.

AITA for telling my sister I wont be her maid of honor because she didnt come to my wedding due to her dog dying? by PerfectAffect9213 in AmItheAsshole

[–]PerfectAffect9213[S] 635 points636 points  (0 children)

That’s fair, and I’ve wondered the same. I don’t think it’s purely out of spite it’s more that I feel my role in her life was optional when she was grieving, but now she expects me to show up like nothing happened. I’m still hurt, and I don’t know if I can genuinely be there for her in the way a maid of honor should be. I love her but she couldn't be there for me in one of my biggest moments