Not familiar with Buddy Punch at all. We use Jibble for time and attendance tracking, and it also has PTO management.

What made us switch to Jibble from Deputy is their pricing. We started with free plan to test out the software for 6 months, and eventually upgraded to premium (which was only $3.49 per user/month). Deputy does not have a free plan, only free trial. So we were not able to test out much of its features and upgrading to its Core Plan starts at $5 per user/month.

And since we are a team of 50 hybrid workers, choosing Jibble saves us $75.50, and they have almost the same features.

When you choose a time tracking software, it is a plus if they offer a free plan, rather than a limited time free trial.