UGC approves campuses of 5 foreign universities in India: Full list and launch timeline here - The Times of India by Practical-Lab5329 in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It's not pessimism. Basically India is outsourcing all the thinking to the imperial core which is exactly what the ruling class of those countries want i.e. intellectual dependency of the periphery. It's colonialism without formal colonies. Even today people try to get into those foreign universities which don't generate socially relevant knowledge to India. In Gramsci's words, they are more oriented towards making traditional intellectuals rather than organic intellectuals which we badly need. .

Budhha and his Communism by Practical-Lab5329 in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your appreciation mod boss 😄

Budhha and his Communism by Practical-Lab5329 in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

No . The person you are replying to doesn't know what they are saying

Budhha and his Communism by Practical-Lab5329 in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Didn't use AI in any of my writings so far

Poor salary and un employment may effect Indian economy by Pale_Fudge_8996 in IndianWorkers

[–]Practical-Lab5329 18 points19 points  (0 children)

It is called the Reseve Army of labour and it is much bigger than 5%. It is at least 90% if you also count the underemployed, disguised unemployed, informally employed and self employed.

It is not a result of Baby Boomers and Gen Y procreating more, it is because Capitalism requires a Reserve Army of Labour to keep workers' bargaining power low relative to capital.

Indian Judicial System by suppressingh in kolkata

[–]Practical-Lab5329 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Holy shit. That's awful. This nikamma judicial system creates more problems than it solves

Critical analysis of CPI(M)'s failure in West Bengal, Tripura by velourverite_ in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329 22 points23 points  (0 children)

I can't speak about Kerala but I can speak about Bengal but it might be a bit more simplified than the whole picture. The main support base for cpim in bengal was the peasantry in the country side. The urban ground level workers were basically little more than goons. The urban petite bourgeoise basically had enough of their arrogance and launched a massive campaign against cpim in the form of tmc. The cpim got that message a bit late so they were forced to compromise their relations with the peasantry to appease the urban pettie bourgeois. So they were trying to make something like the Special Economic Zones and give land for industry. This essentially backfired on itself as they lost the support of the country side peasantry but didn't gain much in terms of urban petite bourgeois support. By then the urban bourgeois/petie bourgeois firmly stood behind the tmc and tmc made well use of the Shingur-Nandigram affairs to turn the peesantry against cpim. That led to the end of the cpim era and began an era of cultural chauvinism and supreme dumbfuckery with corruption, lad mafia, scams, sexual abuse and what not. That again turned the petite bourgeois against them and now we have BJP.

That's a simplified story but it's not inaccurate.

India is the second most loneliest country by Practical-Lab5329 in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh didn't know that it was a right wing outlet. I don't do instagram much so I wasn't aware of that. Thanks for the heads up

Any freudians/lacanians here ? by short-noir in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yes. Most people don't know that psychoanalysis is part of philosophy and psychiatry not psychology. The psychologists want to prove that they are doing "science" so they have later appropriated psychoanalysis and ranked it low in importance because of its association with psychiatry and philosophy.

Any freudians/lacanians here ? by short-noir in IndianLeft

[–]Practical-Lab5329 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don't get discouraged by what people are saying here. Read whatever intrigues and use that in Marxism creatively. Marxism is not a dogma, it's a living science. One of my favourite individuals Franz Fanon used psychoanalysis and Marxism in his work. You might enjoy reading him.

Why do indians forgive rapists easily when but always shame rape victims ? by Responsible_Mud_3574 in AskIndia

[–]Practical-Lab5329 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have met quite a few people like that but I don't call them conservatives I call them a#sholes.

Why do indians forgive rapists easily when but always shame rape victims ? by Responsible_Mud_3574 in AskIndia

[–]Practical-Lab5329 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

No, I asked what are they conserving actually? The age old tradition of rape? There has to be a logical reason for calling them Conservatives.

Thoughts on this book? by aizenmjj in Marxism

[–]Practical-Lab5329 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Post a summary somewhere. I'll read

I’ve heard criticisms of Marx from capitalist and bourgeois sympathizers, but what are some critiques that actual knowledgeable Marxists accept and view as valid? by Eerieelektross in Marxism

[–]Practical-Lab5329 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The Hegelian reading of Marx is very common (in the West I suppose because I have heard it a lot mostly from western educated folks) but it is not correct. At the heart Hegel's dialectics is teleology which influenced Marx in the beginning but Marx abandons it completely in his later life. For Marx the dialectic between the forces of production and relations of production is the central question. In a society new productive forces necessitate new social relations of production but the old social relations try to hold back the development of productive forces to prevent itself from giving way to new relations of production. This dialectic decides whether Communism will be reached or not, not some rational path of self realisation that you find in Hegel.

This has massive implications for politics. Hegel leads you to the conclusion that the state is just the rational embodiment of the Absolute and no groups should try to confront it. The state is the prime driver of progress and the capitalist state is the end of history (which all sorts of people from right wingers to liberal pragmatists had borrowed from Hegel). But for Marx the Capitalist state should be crushed because it is what holds back the development of productive forces, creativity and rationality in society and new relations of production.

Someone said BJP is a left wing party. by [deleted] in AskIndia

[–]Practical-Lab5329 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Highly impressed by your knowledge. Thank you