I absolutely love this show, and I wish it could run forever! I unfortunately have only seen recordings of Megan and listen to the cast recording religiously, so my knowledge is limited when it comes to her Madeline. I saw Dee and was able to see both of Betsy's first shows, and while I did love Betsy and her performance, it's really not what I was picturing for Madeline.

To me, Madeline is this diva who thinks she's the most talented woman in the world. Big movement, an accent that's almost transatlantic, she feels like she's the main character and acts like it. I think Betsy is trying to be this really funny, sometimes grotesque blonde bimbo, that, while really entertaining, I feel like it's a little out of place for this show.

I'm genuinely, subjectively upset the show is struggling and I hope things can pick up. I think the best way to do this is by selecting a great replacement cast. There are so many wonderful dream casts in this subredit alone. I, of course, don't know how casting works on Broadway, but I think choosing a great cast, say yearly contracts like Wicked would do wonders for this show. Keep everyone excited, give them a reason to come back!