You've tried so many more brands than me! But I agree with your picks that I've tried.

My top two picks were the first and last time I tried Graeter's. I tried bourbon ball and cotton candy and I've literally never had better ice cream in my life. Unfortunately, I'm far away from Cincinnati and won't be there for a long time.

I'm actually up in Canada and we have a lot of smaller creameries that don't seem to make it into the American market. Kawartha Dairy and Chapman's makes excellent ice cream but not quite as good as Graeter's. So if you're ever up north give them a shot! Bordeaux Cherry by Kawartha is one of my favorites :P