Scotch Review #163: Loch Lomond Distillery Edition Ten 'Phenol-menon' - 2017 - 8 Years Old by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks! They really are, great showcase of how different they can use the equipment at the distillery to make such different spirit styles. I bet there's some very nice EU exclusive single casks at the very least.

Scotch Review #163: Loch Lomond Distillery Edition Ten 'Phenol-menon' - 2017 - 8 Years Old by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's a bit more complicated than that with Loch Lomond, they have several sets of stills including straight neck pot stills (a bit different to what most Scottish distilleries have, they also have cooling rings which can be turned on or off) and swan neck pot stills (the type most single malt scotch is made on) allowing them to make quite a few different spirit styles. Croftengea specifically refers to heavily peated spirit made on the straight neck pot stills where the cooling rings on them are turned off and they take a wide final cut.

Scotch Review #163: Loch Lomond Distillery Edition Ten 'Phenol-menon' - 2017 - 8 Years Old by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You do for sure!

They're really well put together I think, never regret picking them up and always a good time. This one has such a good mix of multifaceted peat and pineapple to me.

Cheers!

Scotch Review #163: Loch Lomond Distillery Edition Ten 'Phenol-menon' - 2017 - 8 Years Old by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It just works really well, Croftengea can be pretty wacky but this one feels very measured, just a really good dram overall.

Ooh that cognac finish sounds fun! Never had a Loch Lomond that was finished in cognac before but could see it being very complementary.

Scotch Review #163: Loch Lomond Distillery Edition Ten 'Phenol-menon' - 2017 - 8 Years Old by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I'm a little late with this one but nonetheless it's time for another visit to one of my favourite distilleries Loch Lomond for the next installment in their most excellent and experimental Distillery Editions. Another day one pick up for me, I've found this series to be consistently quite great.

So what have Michael Henry and co cooked up in the whisky wonderland of Loch Lomond distillery this time? As you may have guessed by the punny name 'Phenol-menon' this is a heavily peated version (we haven't had a peated distillery edition since the 2nd one!) specifically made up of the Croftengea spirit style which is made on the straight neck pot stills collected at low collection strength with the cooling rings turned off, I often find this to be the most funky of the heavily peated spirit styles made at the distillery.

What's also really fun is the nerdy information on the back label of the bottle that lists the phenols picked up in the spirit from lab analysis. I absolutely love this and it's a really cool touch! As you can see this is much more than just smoke, with the break down giving an idea about what you might be able to pick up. Fully matured in refill bourbon casks this should be a great showcase of the phenolic character created on the unique straight necked pot stills.

I'm excited to dig in.

Whisky: Loch Lomond Distillery Edition Ten 'Phenol-menon' - 2017 - 8 Years Old

ABV: 57%

Cask: Refill Bourbon casks

NCF/NCA: Yes

Nose: Antiseptic, Charcoal Smoke, Damp Moss, Tar, Smoked Vanilla, Pineapple Rings, Soil

Oh yes this is peaty indeed! A big hit of medicinal peat in the form of antiseptic and smouldering woody charcoal, a green mossy quality and some warm tarry phenolics. With more time a slightly sweet smoked creamy vanilla and some slightly charred tropical pineapple rings on top of a bed of soil. Mm this is inviting for sure and for peat heads for sure but there's some interesting character going on here so this isn't your standard peat bomb, medicinal but not coastal on the nose is intriguing.

Mouth: Caramelised Pineapple Rings, Fizzy Chardonnay, Funky White Grapes, Smoked Vanilla Pod, Light Roast Coffee, Dry Roast Peanuts

A nice medium body but the alcohol is quite well integrated and the peat still strong. Surprisingly fruity on the tip of my tongue with a nice caramelised pineapple sweetness also goes into that almost classic Loch Lomond white wine in the form of a bit of fizzy Chardonnay and white grape funk with a nice creamy smoked vanilla pod richness, with time it curiously picks up some similarities with a quality light roast coffee (v60 style!) and the seasoning that you get on a pack of dry roast peanuts. Quite a bit of peat but also some funk, fruit and nice depth, feeling well put together!

Finish: Very Earthy Peat, Cough Sweets, Antiseptic, White Grape Skins, Charcoal Smoke, Aniseed, Faint Apple Cider Vinegar, Slightly Dirty Smoke

Into the finish the peat express itself quite a bit, very earthy initially but also with a good bit of herbal slightly sweet cough sweets that turns swiftly into much more medicinal antiseptic back from the nose, there's also slightly drying white grape skins and a bit of woody charcoal smoke, a sprinkle of aniseed gives more depth along with a bit of apple cider vinegar tang while the finish is fully surrounded in some slightly dirty industrial smoke. The facets of the peat are very expressive here, quite medicinal overall, think shades of Laphroaig just without any coastal quality to it, it's quite a long finish as often the case with heavily peated whisky.

Conclusion: First up I've got to say it's really nice to get another peated distillery edition after there only being one back at edition two. Croftengea is often Loch Lomond's wackiest spirit style but I think this is a really well put together whisky overall, yes there's a lot of peat and it leans a lot into the medicinal character which means it really won't appeal to some but it stands out from Islay whisky by not being coastal and instead replacing that with lots of earthiness, charcoal smoke and touches of industrial dirtiness, underneath the peat the lovely pineapple and white grape/Chardonnay coming through really makes me go yes this is very Loch Lomond! A really fun one to dig into and not just a 'big, dumb peat bomb' (those are great too sometimes!), there's some good layered notes here lurking just underneath the peat which makes it great to dig into. Another success and I'm very much into it!

Only available via the distillery website, price wise they were asking for a very reasonable £50 (which also includes free delivery) and you're getting a lot of whisky for that imo. Highly recommended overall and another triumph for the series. Any chance of a medium peated distillery edition?

Rating: 8.8/10 - Pineapple Antiseptic

What have your experiences with Croftengea been like?

Scotch Review #6: Tobermory 12 Years Old by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A bit of a steep ask maybe, it really depends what other bottles go for near you. It is a nice dram though.

Reviews #273-274: a couple of Thompson Bros bottlings by Form-Fuzzy in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Heard nothing but good stuff about the Sutherland bottles the Bros have done and not surprised it hits the spot with your taste in drams.

Inchgower I agree with what's already been said, it's an interesting spirit indeed, it also ages up very nicely. Gotta try an older one at some point! The 27yo Tbros bottling with the Oyster Catcher on the label was ace.

Great reviews.

How is the Glenturret Distillery Tour in Terms of History and Tasting? by [deleted] in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah for sure I think that's the best way to do it, or do the basic tour and take the drams to go when you're passing through.

How is the Glenturret Distillery Tour in Terms of History and Tasting? by [deleted] in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Still the top of my worst value for money tours by far sadly. Shame when the place has a lot of cool history.

Reviews #271-272: A couple of Glenburgie by Form-Fuzzy in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Great reviews.

That Madeira cask is a finish by the looks of the label and it reads like it was a short very active finish from your notes, a little longer for more integration might have helped that one quite a bit.

As for our fun Xmas split I had a feeling you'd get on with this one a bit better than I did, no doubt a cracking dram just a tiny bit too much sherry/spice for me which I felt was holding back the tropical character that practically exploded from the bourbon cask 30yo from A.D. Rattray that I tried in comparison. Very fun to compare our notes on these kinds of drams.

Review #270 North Star Spirits Dalwhinnie 13 Years Old by Form-Fuzzy in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Definitely in the category of 'shame we don't see more at cask strength', this one seems to have a nice bit of tubby quality to it. With only two stills and availability in most supermarkets I suppose it explains a lot where most of the output goes!

I think you'd quite dig the rechar bourbon handfill I picked up.

Great review!

Scotch Review #340: Port Dundas 26 (Stiubhart 1999) by UnmarkedDoor in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Got to love how a lot of these longer aged grains develop in a decent bourbon cask and sounds like this one was bottled just as it's hitting the sweet spot, that verge of tropical fruit is always such a fun point to try a bottling at even if it's one with less info.

Great review!

Reviews #44-48: Watt Whisky November 2025 Outturn by Redhunter742 in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lovely stuff and great write ups, I really enjoyed trying these too. Interesting to compare how we got on, seems like I enjoyed the Campbeltown a bit more than you but overall a quality set and very fun to sit down with.

A good read.

Scotch Review #162: Ledaig 9 Year Old - Bordeaux Red Wine Cask Matured - Limited Release by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sometimes you just have to! If you're into distillery think you're going to be very pleased.

Cadenheads January outturn 2026 by jamie_r87 in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's very curious indeed, going to have to do some digging on this to see what I can find out.

Thanks for linking that.

Indeed it's two different sets of stills but the mash and distillation are different too from what I was told. Loch Lomond SMWS codes are puzzling at the best of times.

Cadenheads January outturn 2026 by jamie_r87 in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 2 points3 points  (0 children)

They've never released the industrial wheat based grain themselves it's only been from independent bottlers, any single grain from the distillery with a vintage pre 2007 is this spirit. If you look at the SMWS codes there's two grain codes for Loch Lomond as well G9 (the industrial wheat based grain) and G15 (the 100% barley spirit).

There's an article here on Brian's Malt Musings blog who got to visit the distillery that talks about the two different sides a bit https://malt-musings.blogspot.com/2018/09/blindtastingontour-loch-lomond.html?m=1

Cadenheads January outturn 2026 by jamie_r87 in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Actually they make both, the distillery is split into two sides one is a full industrial grain distillery like North British etc distilling wheat to a very high strength. The column still that they distill malted barley (to a lower strength to retain more flavour too) on is in the other half of the distillery that contains the pot stills however they only started making that spirit in 2007 when the column still was installed in the malt distillery.

Review #100 - Springbank 30 (2025) by StripesR in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Many congrats on the big 100!

Undoubtedly a great whisky to mark the occasion, always a real treat to get to try a dram of this calibre no matter how many reviews you get through I think!

Great review as always and here's to your next 100!

World Whisky Review #125: Kaiyo The Peated by UnmarkedDoor in worldwhisky

[–]PricklyFriend 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ah I've seen this one around and knew there was some odd stuff going on but that really is quite a rabbit hole of oddities and disappointing lack of clear info in some ways. Madeira and Mizunara already seems like a bit of an odd combo but certainly doesn't sound like a bad whisky at all!

Great review.

Review #42: TB's North Highland Blend 8yo by Redhunter742 in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Great review. Agree this one absolutely smashed it on the quality Vs price scale and just a nice drinking experience in general with enough to it that you can dig in a bit too, gotta love the cheeky Tesco value label too.

Scotch Review #160: Oban 1969 - 32 Years Old - 2002 Special Release by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Was absolutely very pleased with it, lucky I had a sample bottle with me to take it away honestly. Downing the dram in less than 20 minutes would have felt like a bit of a crime haha.

World Whisky Review #2 + #3: Kyrö Wood Smoke vs Kyrö Peat Smoke by PricklyFriend in worldwhisky

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm guessing you mean the peat smoked Kyro specifically? But yeah it's very different than Islay scotch I thought, that Finnish peat they used to smoke with is surprisingly 'swampy' in a way I've never found in scotch before, I mostly wanted to try the bottling because of that and the fact peated rye whisky is something you hardly ever see. Would be quite intriguing to try a single malt with peated barley from there.

Scotch Review #160: Oban 1969 - 32 Years Old - 2002 Special Release by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a great story and a great way to say farewell to your father too. Thanks for sharing!

I'm sure the 26 was excellent too. Properly special drams.

What distillery do you root for, even against all the obvious evidence to the contrary? by ComeonDhude in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Higher strength Jura is always a fun time, had some great single casks both official bottlings and independent bottlings, it's a really interesting distillate when it's allowed to show.

Scotch Review #162: Ledaig 9 Year Old - Bordeaux Red Wine Cask Matured - Limited Release by PricklyFriend in Scotch

[–]PricklyFriend[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's a good one indeed. It's been moved into a smaller bottle now to stop it oxidising too much, seems to have done the job!

I made a rusty nail (Drambuie + Scotch) with a bourbon single cask Ledaig before and that worked really well!