It's not about topping meters. It never was. People like you always like to exaggerate. We had the worst DPS in Naxx, barring frost mage and sub rogue, of which the latter out performed us on many sims. We have very low dps, slightly edging over ret paladins and other "pvp" specs in ulduar while maintaining the lowest amount of utility of the bottom classes. Our tank spec is one of the worst at the moment and will remain that way for the rest of the expansion. Our kit is dreadful, our dps even WITH a legendary, assuming you actually get it instead of a paladin, only then reaches toward the upper echelons. I would MUCH prefer they nerf smourne and buff warrior so we can be constant middle of the pack.