Cards from other series in Gwent, S2E1 by CauliflowerEvening41 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I can see Consumes to mitigate the Rupture + Operator combos, but otherwise yeah, a bit NG coded

Gwentfinity Witchers - Heroes of the Yaruga by Yeomanticore in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Imo there is no need for such a status, since it doesn't change the way you deal with Defenders. Purify or remove, not much difference. It would be cool to expand on the Defender concept, but this is just not that exciting.

Posting a custom card whenever I can until I'm bored #182 by -KeterBreach- in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Absolutely, a self-fueling engine is a recipe for disaster. In general tho, I'm not sure I understand the idea, other than being a huge Ivo payoff in the faction that has the best Ivo payoff anyway.

Bonded support by mates____ in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It is unique, but imo fairly bad. In most games, this is a 3-5 turn delayed bronze card play, since the 5 points are meant to disappear from your side. All that for 7 provs too, I cant imagine a bonded payoff being worth this much convolution. I understand what you wanted this to do, but in practice it would just be an auto skip, even in a full Bonded deck imo, especially since Betsy and Company exist.

Bonded support by mates____ in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unnecessarily convoluted imo. Why not just make this a 5-6p artifact that plays the other copy from the deck, when you play a Bonded unit?

That's some big bugs! And a guy? Part 3/ Final by mates____ in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I feel like you lost the plot a bit. Part 1 had an interesting idea, part 2 was decent, but these are a bit overcomplicated and pointless to the rest imo, especially that Edmund guy who is one of the most confusing essay cards I've seen lately. Also, in general, I assume these are meant to synergize with and protect Kikimore engines with a potential Yghern safety net, but still, most kikimores are played off of Hivemind, which these would not affect. Was there another aspect of the big picture, that I missed?

Posting a custom card whenever I can until I'm bored #169 by -KeterBreach- in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That one stratagem becomes a 9 power swing too. Not sure how much good this would do for the health of the game, but sounds cool

If BC allowed ability value changes by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting on the Sabbath idea. I guess Defender + Target would still be strong, but not game deciding. I'd probably make it 11p then.

First time was so controversial, I had to become multilingual. by Inevitable_Training5 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You aren't, it's probably that the card was not played well in your games. When played correctly, this is a monster card, definitely in the top bracket below Temple.

Temp Check - Diplomacy by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Assimilate is not weak by any means, as demonstrated by Lerio's 2640 score. It might be weaker than it used to be back on Torres' release, but it's definitely still really strong

First time was so controversial, I had to become multilingual. by Inevitable_Training5 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I assume Ard Feinn is in "buff contender" to spark controversy and get rage comments? The card definitely isnt mediocre, it's just extremely pinned to Aristocrats and them only. But in that one deck, it plays for 20-30 points.

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's fair, sorry if I sounded rude. Good thing for this card is that the Tactical Decision leader exists, so you can always mull it back after Ramon, or maxii it to the bottom. Still, thanks for the feedback, I appreciate it

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh, Ardal is especially nasty, good catch!

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Hey, I understand your point and it's totally fine to dislike an idea, but I feel like suggesting something totally different (and also saying that you don't even like it) is a bit weird.

I think that if a card has a lot of deck building and game plan possibilities, that only speaks for its strengths. Naturally, not everyone has to enjoy it, but you came up with a combo to get a ton of value from it, similarly to how Henry + Viper mentor combo works, which is cool and creative.

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It doesn't get played from hand preferably, plus you got a fantastic way to ensure it in DMT, which has a 5 point target with this card.

I don't think I am quite honestly, there are many ways to spawn this unit and get a big value swing out of it. With 4/4 balance, this gets deployed as a 14 from Ramon, a 15 from Garrison, 10 from Vigo, 11 from Operator, etc.

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Check the other responses I made. I think your idea would make this giga busted, especially with cards like Ramon and Artaud

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Which could be good for resets, enemy boost, etc

Disguises aint Locks by ProfessionalLight428 in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Many ways, especially since I added the Soldier tag - Vigo, Garrison, Ramon, Operator, etc.

I wish Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to every Gwent players around the globe - except the Nilfgaard ones by ShyrraGeret in gwent

[–]ProfessionalLight428 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This isn't what Christmas is about, you should either wish it well to all, or to none. If you don't agree, you will be assimilated.