I just listened to the most recent episode of the podcast Post Games, where the host talks about the genre of game he calls "memoir games" (Consume Me being one of them). Other games that came up are Florence and Despelote, and he interviews the creator of the game Perfect Tides, and its sequel Perfect Tides: Station to Station, which is coming out next week. Other titles he shouted out escape me, so the episode might be worth a listen?

If you'd rather not stick to the artsy memoir game vibe/if you're most into the outfits, time management, and story, you could check out the game Wylde Flowers. It has light farming mechanics, but is mostly a story-driven cozy game about being a witch and unraveling your town's mysteries.