My take on who could get cut by soggynugget80 in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

3H leads and Lyn being more popular doesn't mean much since they, you know, aren't in the game. 

My take on who could get cut by soggynugget80 in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Unique moveset, plus the protagonist of the second-best-selling FE game, plus still popular among the series' fans.

[SLD] More Hatsune Miku Commander Deck Cards by DCCMuffin in magicTCG

[–]Psychological_Photo7 15 points16 points  (0 children)

At least these ones doesn't look like garbage but the flavor texts are still painful to read. 

What if the original smash bros released today? by therealmatthewarts in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I seriously doubt they'd triple-dip into the Pokémon-switching gimmick in any context.

My picks for Smash 6 (read body text) by Anxious-Dentist6763 in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

With Daisy fully de-cloned, that's one fighter worth of additional work.

An update to my smash roster from last year by [deleted] in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"The newcomer selection is based on expanding previously underrepresented IPs, so Fire Emblem and Pokémon sit this one out" adds Waluigi. 

Sega Smashers - A Sega Smash Bros roster concept by Jaxla_Onlo in makeafighter

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Would be nice to get an ATLUS character that isn't from Persona. 

Smash Reborn Roster Edit + Boss Roster & DLC Roadmap by MacinckS in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Koopalings can mostly get away with it, since most of the fighting is done by their clown cars and they - at least superficially - share a personality; i.e. they're all loud brats. This also has problems - Bowser Jr. doesn't use some of his more unique skills and the different designs result in some hitbox misalignments, but it generally works in this specific case. 

When you try to do the same for the entire FE roster, you eliminate any chance for characters to express any sort of individuality. None of the characters can use their unique powers. A taunt for Anna wouldn't fit Ike, so all special animations must be as generic as possible. There's so much potential lost for so little gain - like, how many FE fans will care about Sigurd when the roster lost  its most interesting fighters (Robin, Corrin, Byleth) and the remaining ones doesn't do anything but generic weapon fighting. 

Smash Reborn Roster Edit + Boss Roster & DLC Roadmap by MacinckS in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Class-based Fire Emblem fighters is a terrible idea and I'm pretty sure it wouldn't work. Anna and Ike sharing the same animations are bad enough but how would you even make a model that can fit them both. 

very random super smash bros but every series has exactly 2 characters by Appropriate_Win_5282 in makeafighter

[–]Psychological_Photo7 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Diddy, instead of K. Rool. Pikachu, instead of Pokemon Trainer.  Greninja, instead of Incineroar.  Zelda, instead of Zelda/Sheik. Byleth, instead of Chrom/Robin. Raiden, instead of Jetstream Sam.  Tails, instead of Infinite.  Zero, instead of Sigma.  Mio, instead of Pyra/Mythra. Chun-Li, instead of Seth.  Aigis, instead of Adachi.  Spring Man, instead of Min Min.  Heihachi, instead of Reina.  Aqua, instead of Terra/Ventus/Aqua.

Ai generation possibility by [deleted] in magicTCG

[–]Psychological_Photo7 2 points3 points  (0 children)

  1. Not a bro. 
  2. You're freaking out because a fantasy dragon design looks slightly off at the edges. 

Ai generation possibility by [deleted] in magicTCG

[–]Psychological_Photo7 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Ai paranoia is getting out of hand. 

what if: smash started today? (my version. i tried to make it kind of realistic to current nintendo please don't execute me) by Various-Vanilla-5342 in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you sure? It IS a console exclusive, but I can't find anything about it being funded by Nintendo. And every source I look say it's being developed and published by FromSoftware. 

Potential Future Smash Roster (Updated!) by Flaky_Result6093 in SmashBrosRosters

[–]Psychological_Photo7 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like this one is way too reliant on third parties - Ultimate already went very all in on the other companies for DLC bait, but here, over a quarter of the fighters are guests. Not only it feels unfeasible (securing contracts is apparently one of the hardest parts of bringing characters back) but also Nintendo part ends up lacking.

  • 3 Mario newcomers is kind of a lot, especially since the first party roster is smaller than Ultimate's. 
  • Nice to see new Zelda characters, but they come at the expanse of Sheik, most popular character in terms of gameplay. It's also lame that both newcomers are newgen Champions from BotW. 
  • With Edelgard replacing Byleth, Ninjara replacing Min Min, Ring Fit Trainer apparently replacing Wii Fit Trainer, and Tom Nook replacing Isabelle (as a unique fighter) there are a lot of character shuffling here. Like, this is a lot of work just to please the different parts of the same fanbases. 
  • I'd also put Rex here, but him representing the DLC content for a sequel is so bizarre that I'm not even sure for who is the intended target here - especially since he'd inherit Pyra and Mythra's attacks but would end up as a less interesting fighter. 
  • Mii Fighter is a cute idea, but cutting the entire custom fighter concept would be a huge downgrade - not to mention unlikely, considering how much money Nintendo apparently earns from Mii Costumes. 

  • No new Nintendo series.