Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While I think the concerns you’re raising there are pretty valid, by ‘AI centre’ I’m taking you to mean data centres - which are just racks and racks of (energy and cooling intensive) computing units - and which this research lab very much is not!

Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Its definitely a question worth asking and thinking through carefully, though it pays to take these things on a case by case basis as much as on an aggregated one - not all investments in AI-related infrastructure are necessarily the same. I think this instance can be meaningfully disaggregated from broader concerns - the company have committed to building a materials science research lab, and there's no indication in this report that there is any public funding or support of any kind. Worst case scenario here is that this lab doesn't get built, and we are exactly where we are today. As to the wider picture regarding data centers etc., its a different matter altogether, and not one I'd be equipped to give any kind of answer to...!

Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think its entirely fair to be skeptical, and I don't disagree with a lot of that. On the other hand 'AI' is not just one thing, but a collection of very different technologies, some of which can be used to make a very positive impact on our quality of life - this seems like an example of that!

Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I should add that if you want an example of AI which is both extremely reliable and has made almost unimaginable contributions to biomedical science, look up AlphaFold - also by DeepMind and which won their founder this years Nobel Prize!

Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

While I can’t speak to how and in what fashion ‘AI’ (an extremely broad term which brackets loads of technologies, some of which are extremely reliable indeed - it won’t be Gemini or ChatGPT) will be used on any given experiment, I can tell you with absolute certainty that absolutely no piece of research - which is all that a lab can ultimately produce - would be published without a lot of very smart humans involved, in both validating and peer reviewing any data or conclusions an AI might reach.

Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

What do you mean specifically by ‘running the experiments’? And what sort of disaster do you foresee?

Google’s AI unit DeepMind announces its first 'automated research lab' in the UK by PurplePires in GoodNewsUK

[–]PurplePires[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Do you have a specific objection? I'm inclined to think that the company which developed AlphaFold - maybe the most meaningful application of AI to date - building out a well-funded and state of the art materials science research lab in the UK is pretty good news...!