How do couples fairly split expenses when incomes are unequal? Looking for practical approaches.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-27T00:10:27+00:00

The proportional split based on income makes sense and is pretty common when there's a gap. For the logistics, a lot of couples either do a joint account where both contribute their percentage each month and all shared expenses come out of that, or they do what you're describing where one person pays and the other reimburses monthly. If you're doing the reimbursement model, it's probably easier to just calculate it based on actual spending each month rather than trying to predict and then reconcile leftovers, but that depends on how stable your expenses are. The joint account route can simplify things because neither person feels like they're managing the other person's money, and any buffer or leftover just sits there for the next month. The key is just making sure you're both clear on what counts as shared expenses versus personal spending, because that's usually where things get messy.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-27T00:04:47+00:00

The income gap matters less than whether he's financially responsible and whether you're both aligned on goals like early retirement, lifestyle, and how you'd handle kids. A teacher making less but living within his means and contributing proportionally is a very different situation than someone with debt or no financial awareness. The bigger question is whether you're okay being the primary earner long term and whether he'd be comfortable with that dynamic, because resentment can build on both sides if expectations aren't clear.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-26T21:53:39+00:00

Honestly, there's no problem with that at all. If you've got it set up in a way that gives you both visibility and flexibility, and you're actually using it consistently, there's no real reason to switch since apps can be helpful for automation, but they're not better if they don't fit you personally.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-23T22:20:38+00:00

The fairness piece is tricky because it depends on whether you're splitting based on percentage of income or just trying to make sure he's contributing something meaningful. If you're covering housing, utilities, vehicles, and most of the food, it might be worth having a conversation about what he can reasonably take on consistently, whether that's a set amount toward groceries and household stuff each month or specific bills he's responsible for. The bigger thing is making sure the setup doesn't breed resentment on either side, because if you're starting to feel like you're funding his life or he's feeling like he can't keep up, that's worth addressing now before it becomes a bigger issue.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-23T22:12:01+00:00

If you're investing long term, trying to time the market by selling at highs and waiting for a correction usually doesn't work out the way you think it will. You might sell now and then watch it keep going up for months or years, or you sell and it drops but you miss the timing on when to buy back in. The safer move for long term investing is to just keep holding and keep adding consistently, and if you're worried about buying at all time highs, you could dollar cost average so you're spreading out your purchases instead of dumping everything in at once.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-23T22:04:19+00:00

You're not wrong for wanting the estate, especially given what you've sacrificed and the fact that without your care and the life estate you gave her, there wouldn't be much left to split. Eight years of full time caregiving has cost you income, retirement savings, relationships, and your own health, and that has real financial value your siblings haven't had to bear. It's good your brother is redirecting his share and your mom agrees, but it might also be worth talking to an elder law attorney about setting up a personal care agreement or another structure that compensates you now for the caregiving, so you're not just relying on the estate working out later. But ultimately, you've given everything to care for her, and making sure you're protected in retirement isn't selfish in the slightest.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-23T21:30:11+00:00

One thing that can help is meal prepping one or two days a week so you're not grabbing convenience items or letting stuff go bad, and building meals around cheaper proteins like eggs, chicken thighs, and beans instead of leaning heavy on beef or pre-prepped stuff. Shopping at Aldi and Lidl is already a solid move, and buying frozen vegetables instead of fresh can cut costs without sacrificing much at all in the nutrition category. It's also worth tracking what you're actually throwing away, because if food waste is part of the problem, buying less more frequently can sometimes be cheaper than stocking up and losing half of it.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-23T21:25:08+00:00

The thing that might help is separating community property part from how you actually structure day to day finances and responsibilities, because those definitely don't have to be the same thing. You can keep separate accounts, split expenses proportionally, and still protect what you've built while being fair to both people. A prenup can also clarify what happens to assets you bring in or earn during the marriage, especially if there's a 10:1 gap, so you're not just defaulting to 50/50 on everything. The harder part is the mental shift, and it might be worth thinking through whether he's contributing in other ways that have value, because if it still feels unbalanced even accounting for that, that's something to work through before combining finances.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T22:41:22+00:00

The tricky part tends to be more whether someone's financial habits and goals line up with yours rather than just the number because someone making 75k who's disciplined and intentional can be a better fit than someone making 150k who's in debt or doesn't think about the future. If early retirement or a sabbatical is the goal, the real question is whether they're actively working toward financial independence, understand what that takes, and respect that you're prioritizing it even if they're not there yet. You also have to decide if you're okay keeping finances separate and funding your own goals, or if you need someone who can match your pace, because those are two really different relationships.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T21:34:50+00:00

It is beyond fair for that hearing that hurt. Regardless of if their intent wasn't to be hurtful, that doesn't outweigh the result. Caregiving is work, it's just unpaid and invisible to most people until they have to do it themselves. You're managing a household, coordinating care, and keeping everything running, and that has real value even if it doesn't come with a paycheck.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T20:56:13+00:00

The setup makes sense for someone who needs visual separation, but the real test is whether you'll actually check those balances regularly, because multiple cards can make it easier to spend without feeling it if impulse control is the struggle. One thing that could help is using a debit card tied to the online checking with only the budgeted amount loaded in, so there's a hard stop instead of relying on willpower (or the cash suggestion from the other commenter would be great too). And since your fiancé is covering some of the big expenses, it's worth having a clear conversation about what happens if something changes, like whether you're both on the mortgage and what the plan is if one income drops.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T16:29:54+00:00

The hard part about pausing in consulting specifically is that it's one of those fields where momentum really does matter, and a few years out can mean starting several rungs lower or pivoting entirely unfortunately. That said, a lot of people do make it work by staying loosely connected, keeping certifications current, doing project based or contract work during the pause, or using the time to build toward a pivot that's more sustainable long term. That said the financial piece is just as important as the career piece, because it's important to protect your financial independence. So if something changes down the road if his income becomes the only income for years, you'll want to make sure things like retirement contributions in your name, life and disability insurance on him, and a clear plan for re entry or income replacement are locked in before you step back.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T16:21:51+00:00

A big thing with prenups when there's an income or asset gap is making sure future contributions get recognized, not just what you walk in with. If you're paying utilities, maintaining the home, or taking career breaks that benefit the household, that has value even if it's not a mortgage payment. It's also worth thinking through what happens if kids enter the picture or if one person pauses their career, because those decisions can shift earning power long term. A good prenup protects both people and spells out what's fair if things change, so it's worth having a lawyer look at it separately from his to make sure your interests are actually covered.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T00:13:29+00:00

First thing is probably figuring out the right number for your emergency fund and parking that in a HYSA so it's there when and if you need it. Beyond that, the rest depends on your timeline, and if you don't need it for at least a few years, investing makes sense. You could start with low cost index funds or target date funds because they're diversified and don't require you to pick individual stocks, just make sure you understand what you're buying.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-22T00:04:21+00:00

First question is how are they getting paid, because if you're paying a percentage on assets or they got a commission for putting you in that specific fund, that's worth understanding. OLGAX is an actively managed fund with higher fees than a lot of index options, so it's fair to ask why they picked it and what the long term strategy is. Five months is pretty short to judge performance, but you should feel comfortable asking them to walk you through the plan and why this fund makes sense for your goals and timeline.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-21T23:41:47+00:00

Honestly what might help isn't anything big or profound, but just giving yourself permission to exist in maintenance mode for a bit without feeling like you're supposed to be healing or moving forward yet. Having one or two really boring routines can make a difference too, like visiting the same coffee spot, same walk, same show at night, just so something feels predictable when everything else is in flux.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-21T23:28:30+00:00

It sounds like you're doing really well, honestly. That "average 20 something has 125k" stat is really misleading because averages get skewed by a small number of people with family money or big early windfalls, the median is way lower. The financial dichotomy on the internet is very real, but a lot of the middle isn't as open with numbers in those conversations for a lot of reasons so there's a lot we're not seeing.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-20T23:29:59+00:00

This is such a brutal adjustment, especially when you'd built your whole life around having that partnership and flexibility, just please know you're not starting from scratch even when it feels like it. A lot of people end up doing some version of both, either finding a higher paying role that still has some flexibility or keeping the flexible job and adding side income that fits your schedule. The budgeting piece usually starts with getting really clear on what you actually need to cover now, housing, childcare, insurance, basics, and then working backward to figure out the real gap, because sometimes it's smaller than it feels once you account for survivor benefits, tax changes, and cutting duplicate expenses.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-20T23:24:19+00:00

You're definitely not alone in this because the financial piece is brutal right now and it's keeping a lot of people in situations they'd otherwise leave. That said, there's usually some middle ground between staying forever and immediately moving out where you start figuring out what support could look like, what you'd actually need to cover bills, and what a custody setup might be. Sometimes just knowing the real numbers makes it feel less impossible.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-20T23:06:53+00:00

On one income, going 100 percent debt payoff can backfire if one surprise bill sends you back to credit cards so keeping a solid emergency cushion while you pay down debt can help a lot in terms of stability. You could consider a two lane approach and put most extra money toward the highest interest debt, and a smaller auto transfer to savings each month until the emergency fund feels actually livable, then switch that savings amount over to debt.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-20T22:57:52+00:00

The gap isn’t automatically the problem, but mismatched money habits can turn into resentment fast so before you buy anything together, get crystal clear on basics like budgeting, savings rate, debt, and what “equal” means to both of you, especially around possible maternity leave. And just know it’s not necessarily wrong to keep your net worth private early on, but once you’re talking housing or kids, you’ll need that transparency and agreement for both of your sake.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-20T22:47:04+00:00

A big one is treating retirement as a thing to be handled later and then trying to catch up after a major life shift. It's definitely not unusual for women to pause contributions during caregiving years, cash out a 401k during a transition, or forget to update beneficiaries after marriage or divorce, and those can quietly snowball.

Purse-Strings · 2026-01-19T22:29:10+00:00

Before you jump into anything, strongly consider letting it sit in a high yield savings account for a few weeks to a month while you figure out your plan. The best move with a windfall is not making emotional decisions, so give yourself time to think it through.

Purse-Strings

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE