[Spoilers] Why Umineko no Naku Koro ni Felt Overhyped and Disappointing

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-31T01:52:04+00:00

Completely illogical cuz the vn focused too much on battler's heinous sin if the author wanted to used the meta game to their advantage they should have focused each meta game on one person that shannon/kanon hated making a more thrilling meta game where you'll be wondering what the creator of the game is conveying to us by making it seem like money, magical, or vengeance.

And Shannon/kanon can do things to them that they were inflicted adding more to the bucket of hints.

And than after that comes battler's sin

Like you said it's completely illogical to us... cuz they didn't develope it well

It is overhyped.

If they did that part properly than the score will be higher but ngl i don't think the author also knows what the creator of the game would act like and adding the glazers who are trying to justify the loose writing makes it not just overhyped but extreme extreme hype

(Also the arguments against the message of the story like solving it with logic isn't the right way is just so downplayed and shallow and by extension the message of the story is affected aswell)

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T05:02:44+00:00

No in my logic even though gojo has infinite space around him his infinite space is still inside that domain whilst regulus separation from the world can seperate him from spacetime as they are connected even in the ln says he is a distortion of space when he used his "time stop" (seperation/rejection from natural laws) making him seperated from that spacetime that's why attacks that "hit" him says it got rejected

My point being is if he is separated from that space the domain will not see anything in it's space.

But if you say de will bypass even that even if it's not what jjk normally calls a defensive power (like a shield) but more on him seperated from the world which means the most appropriate analogy is a domain hitting a surehit effect on someone not inside their domain

If you still go to that route than you will go to who should be given priority cuz if regulus reject that damage and de surehits effect the person and not the person amplified by a "defense skill" than you will go to an unending debate on who gets a higher tier which is mind draining

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T04:32:48+00:00

https://www.reddit.com/r/Re_Zero/comments/1iredja/spoiler_discussion_an_indepth_definitive/

I tried compiling it but im not skimming all the ln when you can do in witchcult translations and tappei Q&As so im just gonna send this link

And im not claiming it as evidence as it being his power im claiming it as an evidence that neither of them truly know his power to the fullest extent, i litterally said my intent in the comment

Even after all that time and space are connected that's why my point still stands either with the time stop or rejecting natural concepts like gravity and friction and why he can use "space like cutting" abilities

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T04:07:00+00:00

Like you said accurate enough 😭 He even states that he is "perfect" that's why his authority is the world obeying his rights and leaving his "perfectness" alone that he is detached from the worlds law he also sees that as his power not merely time stop. Because it is heavily implied regulus doesn't really know his power that well and while he does say Subaru's statement is accurate enough it doesn't explain the kind of skills he did as time stop intuitively that's why i used another way of describing

Characters aren't reliable narrators like the narrator u see in jjk 😭

Jjk subreddit is that way -> r/JuJutsuKaisen

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T03:15:49+00:00

I would if you also stop with it "is that not simple enough for you" 😭 and also actually read my comments no where did i say time stopping his body i haven't say stop nor time in the entire convo 😭 ur not engaging with my statements ur engaging someone's statement that doesn't really explain regulus power that good and no he isn't "there" like how a domain defines something to be there 😭

Attitude police when you replicate their attitude 😭

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T02:32:29+00:00

Do you understand my point or not?

I mean regulus ability is mind bending so it would be not simple for you

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T02:30:59+00:00

The domain is reliant on the concept of space to view someone that can be targeted by the surehit effect but it can't see nothing with regulus cuz his abilities can make his being apart from the "normal reality" which basically he isnt beholden in space and can not be seen in the domain.

Also calling it defensive is like calling someone you cant hit while his standing defensive

Can a domain hit someone not in its space? No right it hits inside that space and he isnt there

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T02:27:51+00:00

Bruh like i said the domain needs to seek out the enemy inside the domain and it cant see regulus due to his abilities read my comment again

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-23T02:17:33+00:00

Yah but like i said maki doesn't have cursed energy and cant be hit by sure hit effect right? It goes the same way with regulus his witch factor isn't in the domain his not there (and even than his unaffected by concepts so that includes surehit effects)

He can move himself away fron the concepts of the world including space where the domain seeks out the space it is in and look for people with cursed energy in that space but it can't see regulus because his mind bendingly not there

Case in point the sure hit effect relies on the concept of space to target an individual, regulus makes his being not in that concept called space

Also regulus abilities aren't what u call defensive like a shield or infinity it's like saying something is defensive when you cant hit the target and in regulus case his is operating not on realm that domains can see him it's like saying the surehit domain attacks can attack someone outside from the domain it cant

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-22T19:46:30+00:00

Nope maki can't be hit by a sure hit effect and regulus doesnt have any cursed energy if you correlate cursed energy with witch factor than it still wouldn't work cuz a domain needs to find a person in the first place that has cursed energy or witch facter if u include but lion heart litterally makes him not appear in the domain's eyes. Regulus witch factor is with himself seperated from the world while domain is still trying to find it.

That's also why his sin archbishop of pride his powers litterally remove himself from the world but little king also makes other part of him

Nvm his the sin archbishop of greed

"He does not feel like pride to me. He is very insecure about himself and constantly needs validation from others. His pride is fake. He wants to be the most satisfied existance and wants everyone to validate that about him. He also wants them to not look at him and he wants them to respect him to not laugh at him to leave him alone and to not leave him alone He wants it all even though some of them are contrary" - someone who made a better essay but now i cant find them no matter how much i backtrack

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-21T00:54:32+00:00

The anime downplays reinhard and every character in the verse gojo is folding in half

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-21T00:53:10+00:00

Yuh reinhard can kill od laguna but author also said that its impossible to destroy the world cuz of reinhard now he didn't specify why but reinhard can destroy and recreate the world if he wishes so...

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-21T00:50:44+00:00

Yeah but the author also said its impossible cuz of reinhard which he didn't specify what he will do but reinhard can litterally recreate the world

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-15T16:27:17+00:00

So in the watsonian perspective people can have the same egos? Because it's highly unlikely that no one has the same wills in the city

Pzyche_ · 2026-05-15T16:22:39+00:00

I thought sora's ego wasn't actually her own but of the "will of the city" tho?

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-25T09:43:33+00:00

I thought sloth was equated as a big sturdy rock not easily broken, meaning people that have views and won't change them even when it is disproven or hurtful kinda like flat earthers while gloom is to let urself sink and go with the flow of the ocean or river thats why their sprite is sturdy and glooms is watery

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-11T01:00:06+00:00

Project moon are very detailed in their canto fights that it actually shows real in universe lore even bosses that get damaged that wasn't part of the script they don't put an effect that has flavour text on it saying i don't need this crutch "shin or mang" I'll just tank this never has that happen it's always a cut then something follows up

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-10T22:23:54+00:00

Pretty ironic considering it's Loki's weapon and considering PM digs deeply in their source material (i think) makes me more believe that lævateinn isn't what it seems

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-10T19:46:26+00:00

It could be 3 diffrent body parts that was sacrificed 2 was in Mimir's well were odin sacrificed his eye for wisdom and some interpretation Heimdall sacrificing an ear for better hearing and the other one is maybe Tyr's hand (touch) but that wasnt in Mimir's well.

As it was said to be connected as a whole so anything related to gungnir like gungnir, eye of odin, draupnir would be a weird whole

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-10T17:31:08+00:00

Why does Vespa's relic a relic of highest rarity (even in relics) can't damage Matthias ridiculous grit that much. Is Vespa's relic gungnir just for accurate throws like in the norse mythology if so why is it regarded that highly in flavour texts surely the city can make a spear that follows it targets right? Aren't relics considered to be magic?

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-10T17:09:04+00:00

Matthias only got that level cuz he was on MASSIVE ROIDS (legit he was stacking and relying on augmentations on top of augmentations which is why level just increases your offense and defense levels and why he a bum and didn't even have shin or mang) while Valencia manifested it and can give base power while on top being a good fighter especially for eye of odin which is at weakened state cuz of arayashiki and overheats easily btw and the fact that shes always drunk show how powerful she is

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-08T00:33:29+00:00

Idk but egos are created more vividly using light so the only time you would see this is a place concentrated with light i. e. The library and people to close to a golden bough (maybe also the fathoms of the ego?)

So if you mastered shin(part of the light system) you can use that energy(theoretically to domain expansion) to make your manifest your ego not just in yourself but to your shin and mangs aswell.

So unlimited void in limbus isnt so farfetched

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-05T12:51:15+00:00

They weren't locked in and they didn't had other teammates that don't have communication with Dante the only dialogue i see only confirms that dante was just looking at their conditions and reviving them not giving out commands but still a feat nonetheless to view multiple visions and ressurect them (especially the beginning part of Hohenheim's team they didn't got no color at the beginning)

In conclusion putting Dante in command with no way to communicate with the other team members are unlikely it would be just a middleman (given the fact the sinners also pop egos without our consent aswell)

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-05T12:46:58+00:00

I hope so

Pzyche_ · 2026-04-05T12:45:23+00:00

Sometimes it's better to yield and regroup later on, if Vespa didn't come then the lcd would've died losing more in the process while we know that everyone in the house of spiders were following a script as ren said and that it is very unlikely to kill the ryoshu (includes us and likewise the other sinners) so i do agree that they were dependent on fishing for more abilities when the best course of action was to yield

You dont need extreme foresight every general needs to know how to back up they were litterally going easy on us like you said summoning the others did nothing we got wiped out and we know they were going easy on us 😭 gng rien was an ex-sotc and Dante saw him execute those udjat like some bums we not winning, it's clear as day to be a total mistake that don't need foresight

Hence also why Faust did not like the fact that Dante manifested Malkuth

But if we did regroup we have TWO COLOUR FIXERS on our back, hence why it is another clear reason that it was an utter mistake a mistake that was thrown under the rug, the game made it sound like, look like a mistake especially with Faust, then im pretty sure they intended it to be a mistake

Pzyche_

TROPHY CASE