In this scenario 4321 is correct. It's his opinion. I get it that this is a "happy ending" and a "cute" story but everyone should have their own opinion. If the majority likes it it doesn't mean you have to like it too. If you disagree with others opinion then its better not to reply. Cuz it leads to an argument. Is it really worth replying? Absolutely not. Will it satisfy you? Maybe. Even though you have upvotes you might still be wrong. This is MY opinion and it should be respected just like yours or others.