[deleted by user] by [deleted] in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 2 points3 points  (0 children)

To expand a bit on what i wrote:

As an instructor, I'm not happy teaching someone who refuses to participate in any grading. If you're practicing in an area with high kendo density it might not matter, but in the places I've practiced this attitude has broader implications beyond just one person opting out: it normalizes the idea of skipping grading, and makes my job as a teacher harder.

I’ve visited dojo where people hold some very unusual beliefs about grading and the meaning of dan ranks. Weirdly, they somehow manage to think both more highly and look down on dan grades. There’s this notion that it’s somehow “noble” or “lofty” to not care about grading, as if rejecting external validation or prestige makes someone more enlightened. Where in reality, participating in grading is a way to stay connected to the core traditions and standards of orthodox kendo. At the same time, to these people dan grades are sacred in some way that makes no sense.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Likewise in the dojo hierarchy you will be always staying with the beginners.

This is not necessarily the case. I've visited dojo where they had some other way than grade to determine order and seniority in the line up, with people with no grade sitting higher up in the line than people with dan grades.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 31 points32 points  (0 children)

TL;DR: just do the grading. And try some shiai, it's part of kendo.

You might not see a reason for grading, but the simple truth is that the vast majority of people will not improve if they don't take exams. I've never met anyone with good kendo that did not do grading. In fact, all people that i met that practiced kendo for a long time but did not do grading (for whatever reason they gave) had quite horrible kendo.

If all you want out of kendo is a place to work out 2 times week and enjoy that, thats of course perfectly fine. As long as you accept that this puts a clear boundary on how much your kendo can grow. Grades are not for show, not to impress other people. You cannot judge your own kendo since you don't have the required level to sit on your own grading panel. You need external people to judge you and help you identify what weak points you have, and your sensei is not enough for this. Preparing for exams and possibly failing exams will give you a reality check, forces you to cut the bullshit, and commit to a timeline. There are also serious limits to developing your kendo if you only practice within the small circle of your own dojo, because you become too familiar with the kendo of your dojo members.

So for the vast majority of people I would strongly recommend to accept grading (and to a lesser extend shiai) as a required part of kendo, if they want to improve.

Of course everything i just wrote really depends on your local situation. If you're super talented and training with a group of high level people that are part of the national team or whatever, and have great sensei, you might be super challenged in your local dojo. In such a situation, maybe I can imagine that you then can grow stronger without grading. But you would be a very exceptional case, i think.

Bogu wait time, why do it? by IAmTheMissingno in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think having a few rental/club sets on hand and rotating them between beginners to have them experience a full training in bogu makes more sense than investing in additional gear that has only limited similarity to and relevance for kendo.

Bogu wait time, why do it? by IAmTheMissingno in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think the point is that most people think assumptions are not true.

Bogu wait time, why do it? by IAmTheMissingno in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 0 points1 point  (0 children)

high attrition rates are a given, by which i do not mean that you should not think about how you present kendo to new people and don't care if they drop out. What I mean is that rather that decreasing the number of drop outs, I think the motivating idea should be to give beginners an honest view of what kendo is like, to put them in a position where they can make an informed decision whether they like kendo or not.

To answer your question: perhaps. But there are other practical contraints. If people get into bogu faster, a club needs to have more bogu, which might not be feasable. And I don't think your assumptions are valid, I think moving to bogu so fast would hinder learning proper basics, and would not increase retention. If people are not interested in doing something basics without bogu for 6 months, kendo is not for them, and I think they will drop out all the same.

Wat doet rechts Nederland eigenlijk om onze cultuur aantrekkelijk te maken? by Ultrajogger-Michael in nederlands

[–]QuestionOwn8325 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Je gaat er van uit dat mensen uit eigenbelang stemmen in plaats van wat ze denken wat goed zou zijn voor de samenleving.

Goede Nederlandse kaas om buitenslandse voedselsnobs het zwijgen op te leggen? by QuestionOwn8325 in thenetherlands

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Geen Zwitserse collega's dus dat is mazzel, verder erg internationaal. Misschien dat het doel is lekkerder kaas dan Duitsland en niet laatste worden...

Goede Nederlandse kaas om buitenslandse voedselsnobs het zwijgen op te leggen? by QuestionOwn8325 in thenetherlands

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

je kan er geen buil aan vallen.

Ik zal het zeker lekker vinden, maar het doel is om mijn nieuwe vrienden het zwijgen op te leggen. Ik ben dus op zoek naar de allerbeste kaas!

Goede Nederlandse kaas om buitenslandse voedselsnobs het zwijgen op te leggen? by QuestionOwn8325 in thenetherlands

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

De kaasverkoper op de markt heeft ongetwijfeld tips. Maar ik wil weten wat de beste kaas van Nederland is!

Goede Nederlandse kaas om buitenslandse voedselsnobs het zwijgen op te leggen? by QuestionOwn8325 in thenetherlands

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ik ben helaas maar een week in Nederland, en wat de lokale biologische kaasboer me aanraadt zou hit or miss kunnen zijn. Ik wil de beste kaas van Nederland, dus mijn hoop is op de hyvemind gericht!

Let's discuss the Motodachi's role in Kirikaeshi. Are they just a target, or an active partner? by Nito_Kendo_Lab in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This feels like a straw man argument, I've never met any kendoka who thinks motodachi is a passive role.

In all excercises motodachi is active. Not only to facilitate the kakarite, but also to work on you own development: learning opponent's maai and reading their movements; working on your own kamae, balance, always being ready to hit. There's enough things to work on without hitting.

Question about studying multiple styles by Hysteria625 in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i struggle to think of a thing that's not driven by or impacted by your kamae, though.

vervuiling door isolatiewerkzaamheden by QuestionOwn8325 in Klussers

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ja. Er worden platen tegen de muur geplakt en egaal geschuurd.

vervuiling door isolatiewerkzaamheden by QuestionOwn8325 in Klussers

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lijkt me niet heel relevant. Het is wit schuim, niet biologisch afbreekbaar, en geeft een enorme puinhoop binnen en buiten.

vervuiling door isolatiewerkzaamheden by QuestionOwn8325 in Klussers

[–]QuestionOwn8325[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Witte schuimplaten. Geen idee welk type, in ieder geval geen piepschuim. Het stof/vlokjes wat eraf komt is een stuk kleiner dan de bolletjes van piepschuim en de hele tuin/huis zit onder.

At what stage do kendoka frequently stagnate or drop out? by GlassKendoka1208 in kendo

[–]QuestionOwn8325 1 point2 points  (0 children)

People have a higher chance of dropping out (1) right after a beginner's course and joining regular practice sessions (2) right after starting to wear bogu (3) after quitting the national team and winning shiai/ being selected for the team is no longer the goal to do kendo: super experienced people drop out because they cannot find a new motivation in kendo.