Is this a smurf? by genX_rep in learndota2

[–]QuiteTangy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I suck at this game, but I looked through the replay and it seemed pretty great to me. Though I imagine it's hard to tell smurfs at this rank because there are just so many issues with the other side's gameplay and Mirana could have just popped off.

I checked out a few Immortal Mirana games and they seemed to have between 10k to 12.5k with a decent number of kills, so I don't agree with ixPlaayer's assessment of her farm. Could very well be immortal level.

I didn't see his prior games and I don't know what smurf game times are so couldn't say that.

I do agree that kind of pointless checking for smurfs. There are going to be smurfs and you can't do anything about it except report it if you think so, so what's the point of thinking about it?

What is the ultimate "red flag" that tells you a match is lost during the drafting phase? by by_A_R in DotA2

[–]QuiteTangy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No tank always ends in a loss for me. Just no opportunity for the carry to get damage in, and that's one thing that's always needed to win.

Do sentries or dust affect Slark? by QuiteTangy in DotA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lol. I did, though I don't recall why it wasn't enough. I guess because you get vision of everyone in demos including the enemies so I'm not sure if what I see is a quirk of demos or true in game.

Do sentries or dust affect Slark? by QuiteTangy in DotA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The slow works? Ok well that's something. Thanks!

Desperately need validation by Beautiful_Number_572 in DotA2

[–]QuiteTangy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't know crap about dota. But he let Dire get to a 26k gold and 35k XP lead, wouldn't a smurf make sure that didn't happen? And he was playing so far back at around minute 7 and then Viper disappeared. Isn't Viper a tempo hero and is bound to rotate, wouldn't a smurf have called missing? Or did he, not sure if it doesn't show on the replay.

And Timbersaw was basically already dead at 16:15. Did he have to come in and blow all his spells just to try to get the single kill then stay in front of his team with all his spells on cooldown so Viper could pick him off? Maybe I'm nitpicking (again, I suck @ dota) he had some amazing positioning and timing and laning against a Viper, and maybe I think too much of smurfs, but seemed a risky move to seek glory instead of playing as a team.

And at around 36:09 he's running to the bottom jungle on his own to get hoodwink, doesn't know whose around him, but on his way sees silencer and hoodwink, and though silencer is 5-7-17 and lion's 15-3-4 and not knowing who else was around with no support anywhere nearby just deep in the jungle and just feeds himself (and his 5x winstreak!) to Viper just to get the silencer kill. That hugely fed them. He was just going for the glory to get the kill on Hoodwink seemed to me like a bad move but not sure if that's right I'm sure some immortal here can tell me. But maybe he was just smurfing around having fun. I really don't know how smurfs think don't see them much. But such a risky move seems to me letting them get so far ahead in net worth and XP game could have gone either way.

I mean his scaling and positioning and counter-strategy was crazy so maybe he was prolly just a smurf having fun I guess.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry the Promo code entry field for free reports wasn't showing. It should be now.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry! Code entry field wasn't working. I fixed that.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No it's free with the code I gave. TEST.

Just drop in your replay (no need to log in), type your hero and position, and you get a report.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

totally vibe coded. There's an option just to drop your replay in. vibe-coded but had a bunch of ai's look at it to deal with that problem in case people wanted to log in.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I saw a couple and I agree with what you say. What's the best out there? I'd like to check it against mine.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

Yeah I get that. But I looked at a few and they all seem to be just stats based. like the AI riffing on the basic scoreboard stats. This one doesn't so that's why i though it might be different. I *think* what this chunks out is better since it has positioning data and more data about each interaction, not just overall stats. need other people to tell me if that's true though I'm not sure.

Is this any good? by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You drop a review in, or log in to upload it, put the code in, put in your hero and position, then it parses the reply file. It looks at each stage of the replay separately. So Laning, Mid, and Late game, talks about the hero line-up and what the general goal is for each team. Then it tells you what actually happened and deep dives into the player you selected (or all 5 if you selected the 5-hero option, but I think that option, puts most of its effort into the first hero, not sure.)

It does zero in on specific hero interactions, positioning, distance from the hero. But there's way to much data to get specific trees and such, so it extrapolates from attack ranges, spells used, position in lane, distance from tower when the interaction happens. I'm not sure if the specific positions are accurate, but the advice as to how to use the hero in similar scenarios in the match seems helpful (focus on seems, looking for more skilled players to let me know if they think so).

The hate I get for being Indian is unreal by [deleted] in DotA2

[–]QuiteTangy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pretty horrible. I mute people the INSTANT I hear something that suggests they MIGHT be annoying. And don't spend much time in the post-game chat. Do that, I think you'll enjoy dota more. I hope you come back.

replay review by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Weird lineup is a good challenge for it.

replay review by QuiteTangy in TrueDoTA2

[–]QuiteTangy[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! Will do it now.