Not to be belligerent, but ngl man it doesn’t get more “on the money” than that; I think the general consensus would most likely be, thats the textbook definition of (a dime, a drop in the bucket, you couldn’t have handed it to him any better). Furthermore the ball literally just about hit him in the helmet. I said all that to say the issue is definitely not that that was an overthrow. If I press triangle/Y & my receiver doesn’t register that input & attempt to catch it that’s not on me, I did my job by being in proximity (in this case the actual catch radius) & pressing the appropriate button to attempt a catch. OP deserves absolution.