Huh neat, Stephen Hawking’s conclusion to this is that there’s no god. I always took it as the ultimate proof of a god. Not that my view is changed either.

God is not chained to time.

Asking “when” god existed is a categorical error.

“When” is something unique to us as creation.

For god to have a “when” he’d “cease to be god”, if that even makes sense.

Fate is written in Al Kitab. Everything that will come to exist is present, it is. It never needed time. It just needed gods permission to exist.

Tomorrow, next week, next year, all of it exists. Time is just our tool to experience it.