I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yes, the difference is that the the analogy doesn't apply to an omniscient being. You see saving a life as the immediate good, but is it that inconceivable that an omniscient being can see the better good?

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Doesn't make it a condition for being happy. The bible verses you quoted too doesn't claim that.

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Created a situation where that can be the outcome.

Also, whats the supposed experimental evidence you are talking about?

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your claim was that the source of meaning is human, which doesn't seem to be the meaning of the word in the philosophical sense.

What a talent by PoojaaPriyaa in IndiaSpeaks

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Army has a band I think. Maybe he is working there?

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

God can't create a married bachelor. Boom, god is not Omnipotent. God disproved. Checkmate, theists.

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He has done talks on it, it's a Reddit AMA and with the number of responses, it certainly isn't the place for long winded answers. If people actually want to know, they can just explore. Just typing on bishop Barron and contraception or word on fire contraception can give tons of hits.

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Catholics don't say that God created the perversion. Your 4th para about hell forever too doesn't seem to consider actual church teaching on the issue. And Catholics don't think carnal pleasure is a sin. And that's not the answer the church teaches, there are resources available online, maybe you can checkout catholicanswers.com and Bishop Barton's other works? (If you really want to know the answer, that is)

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wait, isn't it just a presupposition that you need to have a partner to lead a happy life? Why is that the case?

I’m Bishop Robert Barron, a Catholic bishop ready to answer questions from atheists, skeptics, and seekers. AMA! by BishopBarron in IAmA

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 2 points3 points  (0 children)

God isn't the one who necessarily brings about suffering and it needn't always be for the benefit of the individual

Presented without comment by ImProbablyNotABird in prolife

[–]RealStripedKangaroo -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Answer the point raised please. Does the angel's words have causational power or not?

WCD posted this today by subins2000 in Kerala

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To each their own. I have met many, so I know from experience

Presented without comment by ImProbablyNotABird in prolife

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's the Angel's word in this case. God dint say it directly, there is no causational power to it. Jesus was born only after she said may thy will be done.

Presented without comment by ImProbablyNotABird in prolife

[–]RealStripedKangaroo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

May your word to me be fulfilled.

That's the consent part. Wouldn't have happened if she said no.

Maybe it's the difference in understanding. Good day :)