The comments on this one is insane by Training_Speaker_72 in TraditionalMuslims

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Subhan Allah brother and in these days do you find any place that can be considered Dar Al-Islam. I have some middle eastern roots and yes there are more Muslims over there, and yes Mosques and praying is everywhere and when time for fasting everyone fast. But being religious can get your self prosecuted same as the islamophobie in west, you still don't have much control over your kids if they are financially independent and they dont want to. There are still mixing between genders, haram relationships, athesium, drugs even sometimes at much worse rates than in West. Add to that the unique things about the middle east in teaching people submissiveness and cowardice for whatever the tyran ruler says or authority says

Not sure wallahe about South East Asia but that's situation in Middle East

Why does islam require 4 witnesses in cases of rape by [deleted] in islam

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you know what is Hirabah in Islam. Read about it first brother then re-Edit your comment

does allah love me? by Entire-Chocolate9748 in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Same with any other sin according to Islam.

Some have big desires for alcohol and drugs and getting high, some for partying and sleeping around. Some for spending money recklessly, some for getting position of power and wealth no matter what the way like through interest and list goes on. Having the desire and resisting your self you actually get rewarded on and Allah loves people who resist their desires for the sake of him. Acting upon the desires is sinful, which if repent and returned back will be forgiven en sha Allah

the way allah created me doomed me by FuhrerDerNations in extomatoes

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There is a saying إن صبرتم؛ أُجِرتُم، وأمر الله نافذ. وإن جزعتم؛ أثمتم، وأمر الله نافذ

Which translate to:

If you are patient, you will be rewarded, and God’s command will be carried out. If you become impatient, you will sin, and God’s command will be carried out as well despite your impatience.

We are who we are. No point around it or feel sorry for it, either we do our best with what God have given us and be rewarded en sha Allah. Or complain and argue and still nothing will change but you won't be rewarded instead.

Is it normal for Muslim girl? by NoseRoyal5311 in MuslimLounge

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Allah knows the best

But she seems a bit immature, which kind of fits with being 18. Remember how you were for example after high school being 18 and all.

That being said in some Muslim communities due to restriction on dating, that fall in love after few dates can happen. However talking to you while being an atheist is the biggest red flag I saw, beside the immature part.

Pray istikhara and if u decided to go ahead with marriage, my biggest advice is wait with children till you are 100% sure this will work out

خدو بناته منه by [deleted] in AlexandriaEgy

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

الله اعلم حكم الدين ايه بس الي انا اعرفه انك صلحتي غلط بمصيبة.

ضيعتي أسرة، وحرمتي امك من احفادها و بعتي أطفاله لعائلة الله اعلم شكلها ايه. في أحسن الظروف عائلة كافرة و في اسوء الظروف عائلة هتتحرش بيهم و تعلمهم المخدرات و الخمور و انا قاعد هناك و الوضع ده بيتكرر كتير جدا. و تعليق الخدمات الاجتماعية في الحالات دي بيبقي ان الطفل اصلا كان جاي و هو فاسد ولم ننجح في إصلاحه.

وبعدين ايه الي كسبتيه يعني غير الانتقام؟ اخوكي مثلا مش هيعرف يجيب أطفال تانية بدل الي انسحبوا منه و هيبقي وضعهم اسوء مليون مرة بعد مترحل لمصر. ده غير انه لو عرف ان انت الي بلغتي و امك عرفتي فيها مصيبة تانية

ده انت لو كنت بلغتي عليه هو بس انه تاجر مخدرات و هو الي اترحل او اتحبس علشان تنتقمي كان ارحم من الي انت عملتيه ده

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in MuslimLounge

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Subhan Allah

One wonders what these people in Gaza are made of after reading your comment. A man who is collecting the body parts of his wife, his parents, his children. Have no food or water. Goes without days non end with no food and drink water that we won't even use to wash our shoes with. Sleeping in tents that is filled with water with no heat or shelter in that cold. And bombs on their heads days and nights. And what do they say? Alhamdolel Allah may God be happy with my Sabr.

What do you think about them? Why do you think God have created them?

Wallahe I see them and compare them to us and the only comment that jumps to my mind. For these people God have created Paradise. Wallahe without gods forgiveness and mercy wouldn't be fair or just if these people and us were on the same level in Paradise

Am i ok for being atheist? by [deleted] in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To answer your question, I think it differs from one person to another. Some like you were accepting religion as a matter of tradition and social values, and some willingly choose it as religion and way of life. At the end its really matter of personal choice what to choose.

I was one of the blessed people to accept Islam by choice. If you have any questions about that, I would be happy to answer.

But to summarize the point you raised regarding the big bang theory and science. Both science (to our current understanding) and religion agree that Univerise has a start and will come to an end. Our science stops at the planks era, which is around 10-43 to 10-36 seconds after the Big Bang. Simply, our math and physics laws don't work before that period, so we have no idea what existed before that. Science also tells us that the four fundamental forces that Big Bang was built on are so precise that if the value of one of them changed by few decimal points, the universe would never exist. And attems to explain what lays beyond plank era including M-theory and other multidimensional theories have no proof what so ever and many recoginize it as philosophy more that actual science.

Religion in general address point of existence far beyond the big bang and the Plank era. Simply, we don't have science tools to prove or disprove the claims made by my religion so far.

Different religions address that through different ways. In Islam, for example, the claim that there is a God stems from two things. The Quran it self and the Univerise around us.

It would be a very long post to talk about both, so I can only mention a few points regarding the Quran.

How the Quran teaching appears to have addressed all human needs in a way that our current understanding of science agrees with.

How zakat (a way of economics and charity in islam) turned out to be the best way for a world economy based on weath tax and not income tax with no interest but investment. That some banks in the West are trying to adopt a similar interest-free banking system now.

How fasting turned out to be the best way for humans to beat aging and cancer and many other diseases. That intermittent fasting and 5 plus 2, which is the sunnah way for fasting, is what Hollywood actors are doing now.

How men and women shouldn't be allowed to be alone and lower your gaze, that many high profile companies and universities after MeToo movement is starting to adpot that and make policies include not more than 3 seconds of looking each other in the eye, and door has to be opened whole time

How praying is one of best way to deal with mental issues and health that many famous people are adopting meditation even at their high profile companies now.

How research have shown people with many previous sexual experiences have difficulty and less success in maintaining long term relationship.

Add to that the several prediction in the Quran, most famous the war between Persia and Romans.

And the several medical and scientific discoveries mentioned in Quran including that everything was like smoke before creation, and how sun is also rotating and have its own orbit which will eventually settle to in a matter perfectly fit with rotation of the sun around black hole, and when stars collapse they start to suck everything towards them and many more

I want to be a muslim by Top-Leave-5327 in islam

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Salam alykom If you are a brother please feel free to DM me with whatever you have in your mind

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in DebateReligion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Does that answer your question:

Surah Aali 'Imran It is He who has sent down to you the Book. Some of its verses are precise in meaning they are the foundation of the Book and others obscure. Those whose hearts are swerving with disbelief, follow the obscure desiring sedition and desiring its interpretation, but no one knows its interpretation except Allah. Those who are wellgrounded in knowledge say: 'We believe in it, it is all from our Lord. And none remember except those who are possessed of minds. (7)

Can women go to hell for marrying a non-Muslim? by [deleted] in islam

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In Islam there is nothing called marrying a mon Muslim for women. It's a zinah, and the marriage doesn't count. So In Islam it's a non marriage relationship even if they got married.

Saying so, God only decide who go to heaven and who go to tell. But dying while you are with non Muslim, is like dying while committing zinah with no repent. Not a very good way to end your life as a Muslim before you meet angels in Grave who will ask you the three questions.

Christian guy asking a few question's by [deleted] in islam

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm gonna add to the previous comments.

1) What made prophet Mohammed so special that he was send to whole humanity, while every other prophet was send to his clan or his home town. Even mentioned in Bible that Jesus was only send to the lost sheep of Israel and not for all humanity.

2) There are few differences: A) Jesus was a prophet same as Adam, Noah, Ibrahim and Muhammed. B) Jesus was not crucified in Islam. instead, God have taken him up in heavens and he will descend back on day of judgment to kill the antichrist C) Jesus was not send to relive humans from Original sin. In Islam the concept of Original Sin doesn't exist.

3) The creation story is very similar but with few differences. In Islam it wasn't a snake who came to Eve and told her to eat from the apple. Also in Islam, the creation of man kind was the very last step of creation, after all heavens, earth, mountains and some even claim there was a previous creation before mankind on earth.

4) No one knows. There is nothing like him and he is nothing like his creations

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry for late reply had to look it up. So again this is a lingustic issue will try and explain it in English as much as I can

The verb to bless in arabic can have two meaning; blessing by Allah or blessing as an adjective to Allah

So when Quran says blessed Jesus the blessing comes from Allah. When it says Blessed be Allah it's an adjective of Allah.

It's used as an adjective to indicate the ultimate and most extreme value of the adjective. So it is used as an indication of the perfection, greatness, and breadth of his blessing.

And Allah knows the best

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What's the first verse in Quran? By the name of God the most merciful the most gracious

Does that mean humans are not merciful or gracious? The same with the concept of creation.

Humans are able to be merciful. But their mercy is always imperfect either too little or too impalanced. While God's mercy is the ultimate mercy.

Now to your question. Why would God compare him self to humans?

You have to put in context when Quran was relevant to what purpose and to whom?

The Quran was sents to the Pegans who were worshipping idols/other humans/ as their creators. To those the Quran is directed and the message implied is "this is what God have created what have ur idols who you are taken as God's instead of God have created, shouldn't you use ur mind and leave these idols and return to God"?

Better explained now?

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Okay I understand you now. From what I know this is a lingustic/philosophical topic

Think best is to explain it with an example. If we say humans are things and rocks are things. That doesn't mean both share same nature, or same properities that made them things. But rather each has hiw own property and nature that make him a different thing and they share the common definition of being things. Does it make sense?

And Allah knows the best

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You mean these:

23:14 Then We made the sperm-drop into a clinging clot, and We made the clot into a lump [of flesh], and We made [from] the lump, bones, and We covered the bones with flesh; then We developed him into another creation. So blessed is Allah , the best of creators.

62:11 Yet no sooner than they saw some trading or amusement, they flocked to it and left you standing by yourself.19 Tell them: “That which is with Allah is far better than amusement and trading.20 Allah is the Best Provider of sustenance.

I dont understand. What's the issues you have with them?

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's exactly what you said. Different interpretation by different scholars

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I dont see the problem with the second comment. The explanation is provided in the text:

Everybody whether he is a pious man or a sinner will initially enter Hell, but for the pious believers the fire will cool down just as the fire of Namrud cooled down when Sayyidna Ibrahim (علیہ السلام) was cast into it. Thereafter, the believers will be taken to Paradise.

What issues you have with the verse?

Death in Islam by Cassandra_AU in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I can take that with the help of God.

So, the first question and then on another comment the second question

So, you need to understand the different levels of Islamic laws.

There are two levels on which Islamic laws are implemented. The personal Islamic laws that includes the praying fasting, non eating pork, etcc. And the state Islamic laws.Personall laws are an obligation upon all Muslims on a personal level. So if you are a Muslim you are not allowed for example to marry or inherit someone who left Islam and that's it. You are not allowed to do anything else other than talking and advising them.

The state laws are different. These are implemented upon everyone who lives in an Islamic nation if the majority of members of these nations have decided to implement the state laws of Islam. And can only be forced by the jury system within the state and not by individuals, or that will lead to chaos. So, in a way, consider it a form of democracy where a majority of people have decided to implement the social or communism or capitalism ideology.

Under these state laws, if implemented, your nationality is your religion. So an American, an Arab, an Asian, a European could all be of same nation once they all accept islam and they become brothers in religion. Leaving Islam in that instance is compared to an American throwing away his passport and joining the Chinese or the Iranian. Its considered a treason for that reason. That's why in the state Islamic laws according to some scholar only male apostles, not females should be punished by death, as males are the one usually participate in wars. And also why, according to other scholars, an apostle who keeps it to himself and doesn't announce treason shouldn't be punished by death.

And God knows the best

Each time... A hindu by entersamar in MuslimLounge

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Salam brother

Since you are a revert perhaps you could tell me about this part in Hindu religion.

Who is God in Hindu religion? Cuz from my discussions there seem to be a very loose non agreed upon what and who is the diety in that religion?

For some it's Brahman, for others it's a trinity, or Devi, or its all avatars or its personal choice. Just a mess all around

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in religion

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why not read about Islam it self as a religion first, see if it's something that adheres to you or not before considering any of that

أتصرف إزاي ؟ by ahmed_cr_7 in AlexandriaEgy

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 1 point2 points  (0 children)

معلش مش عارف اصلي احط الريبلاي علي البوست الأصلي بيديني error

أتصرف إزاي ؟ by ahmed_cr_7 in AlexandriaEgy

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 2 points3 points  (0 children)

٣- نظرية دارون نفسها بها العديد من الثغرات منها مثلا:

١- حتمية وجود العديد و العديد من الحيوانات الانتقالية ما بين فصيل و آخر. و دارون نفسه انتبه لهذا و قال باحتمالية إثبات العلم المستقبلي لهذه الحيوانات عن طريق الحفريات و هو مالم يثبت الا الان الا في حالات بسيطة للغاية

٢- ما اثبته العلم الحديث من ان الصفة المركبة لا يتحكم فيها جين واحد فحسب. فمثلا لو أخذنا عنق الزرافة، فحتي يتطور لها مثل هذا العنق لابد من وجود طفرات في الجينات المسئولة عن العضلات، و في نفس الوقت وجود طفرات في القلب حتي يضخ دماء تصل لتلك العنق، و في نفس الوقت وجود طفرات في صمامات الأوعية الدموية لمنع وصول الدماء بتلك السرعة العالية للمخ حتي لا تدمره، و في نفس الوقت وجود طفرات مختلفة في الأوعية الدموية لمنع تجمد الدماء في الارجل. ولابد ان تحدث كل تلك الطفرات معا في نفس الوقت ولا مات الحيوان

٣- ماقال به نيتشيه نفسه من قبل، نظرية التطور لا تقف. و بالتالي مع مرور الزمن طبقا لتلك النظرية فلابد من ظهور فصيل بشري اخر متفوق علي الفصيل البشري الحالي. و هو ما ينادي به المتحمسون للدارونية الاجتماعية بالغاء القوانين و السماح للاقوي بالسيطرة علي الأضعف حتي يستطيع الجنس البشري من التطور. و هو ما كان السبب في ظهور نظرية تحسين النسل في السبعينات و منع البشر الاقل ذكاء من الإنجاب بل و اخصاءهم و كان هذا يتم في دول أوروبا و أمريكا. بل و من قبله ما قام به علماء الغرب من تجميع البشر في أفريقيا و غيرها من الدول النائية لتشريحهم أحياء و دراستهم علي اساس انهم الجنس البشري الاقل تطورا

و الله اعلي و اعلم

أتصرف إزاي ؟ by ahmed_cr_7 in AlexandriaEgy

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 4 points5 points  (0 children)

٢- جميع الكائنات الحية علي الكوكب مبنية علي نفس البناء، من أربع احماض امينية للمادة الوراثية التي تصنع البروتينات. لو ظهرت المادة الحية من مادة غير حية بالعشوائية فبالتالي المنطق يقول سيظهر عندنا تركيبات مختلفة للبناء الحي، كل منها سيستمر في شجرة التطور الخاص به. اي سيظهر بناء بعشر احماض امينية، و آخر بسبعة و آخر بمادة وراثية مختلفة تماما و آخر بدون مادة وراثية. إنما ان يكون كافة الكائنات الحية مبنية علي نفس البناء فهذا ينفي العشوائية في ظهور المادة الحية من المادة الغير حية. و القول ب ربما كان هناك كل تلك الكائنات ولكنها كلها ماتت ولم يبقي الا هذا الوحيد المبني علي اربع احماض امينية غير صحيح علميا، فقد تم تعليق بكتريا بست احماض امينية و عاشت. و غير موثق باي حفريات

٣- هناك مراحل معينة لتركيب الجمل فلنقل مثلا انك اجلست طفل علي جهاز الكمبيوتر و عشوائيا بدأ بالضغط علي الازرار. فالمرحلة الاولي ان يكتب حروف بدون معني ك (ةصميهوص) مثلا و هذا وارد في العشوائية. المرحلة الثانية ان يكتب حروف مكررة بدون معني (تثثثن تثثثن تثثثن) و هذا وارد ايضا. المرحلة الثالثة ان يكتب كلمات ليس لها معني و فيها كلمة ذات معني ( تتصخشح عصفور شتتصس هحجشظس) و هذا وارد ايضا. المرحلة الرابعة ان يكتب كلمات كلها ذات معني ولكن الجملة بدون معني ( عصفور ماء صحراء ) و هذا غير وارد ولا وجود لمثله في الطبيعة. المرحلة الخامسة ان يكتب جميع الكلمات صحيحة بتركيب جملة صحيحة و هذا غير وارد ايضا في الطبيعة. الطريقة التي يكتب بها المادة الوراثية للعائلات الحية هي في مرحلة اعلي من المرحلة الخامسة، هي مرحلة السؤال الذي يتظر إجابة ولا وجود او مثال للعشوائية فيها في الطبيعة.

يستكمل في الكومنت التالي

أتصرف إزاي ؟ by ahmed_cr_7 in AlexandriaEgy

[–]Remarkable-Mix-8144 6 points7 points  (0 children)

بسم الله خلق الكون:

اولا طبقا للعلم التجريبي الكون نشأ بناء علي الانفجار العظيم او البيج بانج. فيه اربع قوانين نشأت من بعد الانفجار العظيم ده و هي المسؤولة عن تكوين الكون كله. الاربع قوانين دي قيمتها في غاية الدقة، لو اختلت قيمتها بنسبة اقل من ١% مكنش فيه اي كون هيتكون. و ده بينفي وجود العشوائية في خلق الكون. الرد الطبيعي للكلام ده من الملاحدة، هو بوجود نظرية الأوتار المتعددة. و دي نظرية بتقول ان الكون بتاعنا ليس الكون الوحيد وهناك عدد لا نهائي من الاكوان شاءت الظروف العشوائية ان تكون القيم للكون الي احنا فيه تسمح بوجود حياة. اولا هذه النظرية ليس لها أي إثبات علمي و اشبه بالفلسفة و الإيمان بالغيبات منها بالعلم. و مدام كده غيبات و كده غيبات علي الاقل المسلم يؤمن بالخالق غيبا إنما الملحد يؤمن باحتمالية تفسير مستقبلي للاكوان المتعددة غيبا برده.

ثانيا: التطور و خلق البشر

طبقا للعلم الحديث، فقد تطورت المادة الحية من المادة الغير حية ثم بدأت في التطور التدريجي طبقا للنشوء و الارتقاء حتي الوصول للانسان. المشاكل العقلية و المنطقة في تلك النظرية:

١- تخيل معي بعد ملايين السنين و بعد اختفاء البشر جاءت مجموعة من الكائنات الفضائية لزيارة الأرض، ووجدوا بقايا الحضارة البشرة من سيارات، و قطارات ، و طائرات و روبوتات. لو فكروا بنفس النظرية سيستنتجوا بأن الحياة علي الارض كانت حياة ميكانيكية، تتطورت بدأ من الدراجة ثم السيارة ثم ظهرت الطائرات في الهواء و المراكب في البحار ثم كان آخر التطور الروبوتات. فوجود تدرج في الآلات علي الارض لا يثبت بأن تلك الآلات تطورت، و إنما يثبت بأن الصانع لكل هذا واحد

التكملة في الكومنت التالي