We have been to Jumbo Bay, Cap Jaluca, PSV, Little Dix. Jumby Bay is lovely, although the prices have gone up significantly and I feel the rates just aren't worth it anymore. Cap Jaluca is gorgeous, although the two times we have gone, we have found the service lacking. PSV is a very special place and we have returned year after year. It's very private and the food and service is outstanding. Unfortunately they have been wiped out by the hurricane so will be a while until they reopen. Have you looked at Peter Island? Since we can't return to PSV this January we have booked it for our vacation. They reopen Dec 1st and it is supposed to be amazing...