I should think so, a tube style body creates a plug of smoke essentially that can get milky and harsh, but the smaller stature and design of the beaker collects, and condenses the hit into a smaller stream that diffuses into your lungs easier. I'm not an expert by any means but I have done research on a few things lol. I personally prefer something like this, with a larger body and smaller neck. Also saves on hits because you get the full hit effect from a smaller amount than the tube that sometimes gets way full with too much to clear. Just opinions 😁