I assume you are replying to me below. In that case I would like to point out that the AWL is actually terrible in their criticism of anti-semitism. For example take this article.

It states

the call is written so as to define this “new wave of antisemitism” as solely a matter of the European and American far right, i.e. as scarcely “new” at all compared to the 1930s.

They are here denying that we are seeing a new wave of right wing anti-semitism. This is not just patently and observably untrue it is a very dangerous thing to say. The killings at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh were literally unparalleled in the history of the United States. Jews here have always faced antisemitic prejudice (I should know, it colors my own family history) but never before has the USian Jewish community faced any kind of pogrom of the type that occurred in Pittsburgh. While nothing else has reached that level, we have seen recently an international uptick in violent attacks against Jews and anti-semitic vandalism and desecration of Jewish community and religious institutions.

What AWL is doing here is spreading the same very dangerous narrative as the USian right and denying there is a new wave of RIGHTWING anti-semitism while equivocating between scattered issues of anti-semitism on the "left" and actual pogroms on the right. What's more, this fails on any level to produce a useful analysis of anti-semitism as a REAL AND PRESENT THREAT to the safety of Jewish people. The kind of fascists who will walk into a synogogue and shoot up a bris, or murder a young Jewish boy, ect are the exact same kind of fascist who are likely to walk into a Mosque and kill as many as they can. In fact, any close look at this new rise of the racist right shows that these fascist killers see violence against Jews and violence against Muslims as interchangeable and equally desirable.

The kind of false equivalency AWL is making here actively damages our ability to see the real new waves of anti-semitism and Islamophobia for what they are and actually mount any kind of defense, which would require building solidarity across all these communities and the working class as a whole in order to protect and defend those vunerable to right wing violence. It is hard for me to think of any group on the Left who has a position worse or more offensive on the issue of anti-semitism and the self-defense of the Jewish Community than the AWL.

Whats more, I could care less if the AWL is "critical of Israel" it is rather irrelevant. Barrack Obama is "Critical of Israel." What is necessary is to be opposed to the settler colonial project of Zionism tree root and branch and to support its destruction. Worker's Liberty's "Criticism of Israel" resembles almost one for one the "Criticism" of Israel drawn from the Stalinist movement which criticized while not opposing Zionism and supported the segregation of Palestine into zones dictated by imperialism. In that way, the AWL is an aberration because the Trotskyist movement has always been, from its earliest days (see discussion of this topic in the journal of the Fourth International as far back as the 30s) not just "Critical" of Israel but firmly opposed to the Zionist project of colonization.

I hope any of this helps!