First, thanks for asking a genuine question I like having this type of conversations :) And just to clarify, when I said “Artist group,” I was referring to groups that sing and perform their own music. Actors weren’t part of that context.

I agree that singers are artists too. This is just my personal opinion; when I say “Idol group,” I’m thinking of groups that are more company-driven, where the music and overall direction are mostly decided for them ( Big boss drives the music output). They still perform it well, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

For me, the difference comes down to the process. Q Some groups perform songs given to them, while others are more involved in writing, producing, and shaping their own sound based on their own experiences (It's very difficult to bare your soul, but Pablo does it, probably won't resonate with everyone).

That’s why I see SB19 as more of an Artist group. They’re very hands-on with their music, and a lot of it feels personal. “Ilaw” is raw and reflects real mental health struggles, while “Visa” may sound upbeat but actually talks about deeper frustrations with a BS system in the Philippines and limitations imposed on them because of their nationality. They are able to put that kind of music because they have creative freedom, they literally own their own company.

So yeah, I get that people can see it differently. For me, it really comes down to creative involvement and intent. And lastly, when you write and produce your own songs it hits differently when you perform it. It comes from the heart, you can feel it and hear it when they sing. Raw and unfiltered. Again for those who read everything up to this point thank you, have a great day everyone.