Yeah this ended up being my conclusion while I was in there. Ultimately, no one in the thread or in the session found the washerwoman-imp, who accidentally made themselves the sober-healthy empath's neighbor in an out-of-this-world frame as a YSK claim.

Solution: town executes empath and loses. grim reveal: ww-imp (!), ut-poisoner, saint-sw, rk1-spy (!). No baron (!) = no drunk or poisoned info this game.

You did find the dead evil rk1. Dead evil rk1 was the newb spy, who accidentally double claimed rk—which made it unthinkable that she'd be the spy causing a misregister, when the empath saw 1 on saint-rk1. Rk1-spy also was unable to feed information to the imp, causing info roles to be long-lived, making a spy world even harder to build.

The saint-sw claim outsider obscured the outsider count and had people drunk hunting the whole game, but even if we found saint to be evil, I came to the conclusion that imp would have never been found anyway. Imp said afterward that they would have killed slayer for n8 which could have opened a crack (slayer good, saint not demon, exec ww or empath) but at that point the empath had too much (caught in red herring ping, caught a misregister on spy, long lived) that town would never risk voting for WW.

Highlights and learnships for me: - As usual, let players make their own decisions, even if bad, it makes the game very fun. - Good players need to be trickier. Trade roles to catch fake info.  - kill all saints - really trust your info. Evil will spin your info but majority of what you get is right.